Friday 9 September 2011

News, Views and Music Issue 111 (Top Five): Legendary AAA Court-Cases

There was a time when music was synonymous with court cases, especially in the 1970s when bands fell out not only with themselves but with their managers, so it was a bit of a shock to hear that Gallagher vs Gallagher might be in a court sometime soon. Of course none of the following cases actually involved brothers or family members (although Ray and Dave Davies came close to suing each other quite a few times, not least over each other’s autobiographies) but they are remarkable all the same:

1)    The Who and Kit Lambert vs Shel Talmy (1967) Difficulty: Record producer Talmy was fired during 1966 despite being under contract. Verdict: Amazingly, the case wasn’t settled fully until 2002, when the court’s decided in Talmy’s favour, with an agreement that master-tapes from the period belonged to him, delaying the issue of the ‘My Generation’ album on CD for several years. Even before then, however, it was agreed that Talmy was to receive a quota of the profits made by the band during the time of their contract with Polydor. Who manager Kit Lambert didn’t like Talmy, the man of a million hits who seemed to think he knew ‘better’ than Lambert how to run his group. The band hated him even more, with Pete reduced to pleading to be able to re-cut some tracks on several occasions. But to be fair, Talmy was the man with the track record, even if his hits with The Kinks had also gone wrong under similar circumstances (Ray Davies wasn’t happy with his work either). As a result of the confusion of the legalities of terminating Talmy’s contract and who owned the rights to what recordings, the band’s 1966 single ‘Substitute’ was issued twice, with different B-sides: Talmy’s version contained ‘Instant Party’, a song better known on its later issue as ‘Circles’; the band chose to release a track by the Graham Bond Organization titled ‘Waltz For A Pig’, a title probably aimed at Talmy!  

2)    Paul McCartney vs John Lennon, George Harrison, Richard Starkey and Allen Klein (1970) Difficulty: Paul objected to the others singing Allen Klein up as their manager against his wishes and wanted to disolve The Beatles’ partnership and lave the band’s ‘Apple’ label Verdict: Finally settled in 1974 – in Disneyland, Florida of all places – when John is the last to put his signature to a document agreeing that the four Beatles can go their seperate ways. In the end, all but Lennon re-sign to EMI, leaving John free to become a house-husband free from record companydeadlines. There’s been a changing of opinion over the court case since its announcement in 1970. Back then Paul was seen as the ‘naughty Beatle’, the one who broke up the world’s greatest band for selfish reasons and betrayed the peace and love spirit of the times by dragging his colleagues through the court. After all, Klein’s credentials in 1970 were excellent – with clients including the Rolling Stones earning more money than ever before and no public acknowledgement about just how tough, crude and obstinate Klein could be. But as ever the truth is not that simple: it was Lennon who tried to force his protégé (manager Allen Klein) on the others after Paul had been the band’s de facto manager in the three years after Brian Epstein’s death (when, what with the record-breaking sales for ‘The White Album’ the band had done quite well). The Beatles had also agreed to a pact early on in their pre-fame days that if one of them disagreed with a decision the others would back down without a fight – something that was only really tested by this latest development. Ask most Beatles fans now and they’ll say Paul was right – not least because Klein will end up in prison in the late 70-s for tax evasion and swindling his clients out of money (even Lennon admitted in an interview just before his ‘retirement’ that Paul was ‘probably right’ given the way things had worked out at Apple). Memorable response from George: ‘You’re staying on the label or else! Hare Krishna!’ A negotiation from Ringo as peacemaker ended up with the drummer being forcibly ejected from Paul’s house. The band that had seen it all couldn’t cope with this latest strain of manager changing and the result was the end of the biggest band that ever was.   For more detail visit the extremely detailed week by week guide to the court case at

3)    Gilbert O’ Sullivan vs manager Gordon Mills (1978)    Difficulty: Royalty rates on Gilbert’srecords  Verdict: the court found in Gilbert’s favour, awarding him £7 million in unpaid royalties and handing over control of mastertapes for all albums over to Gilbert to control. Gordon Mills never spoke to him again. Record royalties have always been a source of mystification to me and I’m sure many other music followers: for instance, under the terms of their EMI contract, The Beatles made only a penny a single as late as 1967, a truly awful rate even for the period. But Gilbert’s problem was a bit more complicated. When he first signed up with Mr Mills he was promised 25% of the music rights to his songs and a royalty rate ‘if he was successful’. Now Gilbert was pretty successful you have to say – four top 10 LPs and even more top 10 singles including two number ones – but he never got the royalties he’d been promised. The pair were genuinely friends early on too – Gilbert often babysat Mills’ daughter toddler Clair, which is where the inspiration for one of his most famous songs came from (a song which he vowed never to perform again, only breaking his rule in 2009 long after Mills had died). On leaving Mills’ management in 1975 the pair seemed to have reached an amicable agreement: the money was coming, the singer was promised, but at a later meeting he was told to ‘get lost’ (or something stronger). In Mills’ eyes, he’d already turned Gilbert into a star and made him rich and famous – but the missing money would have made the difference between being affluent and being properly rich. As luck would have it, mild mannered Gilbert was mates with famous entertainment lawyer Gary Davidson and did the unthinkable, suing the man who most musicians cowered in fear from, even though – like McCartney – he suffered many months of agonising over whether he could really sue one of his biggest friends. The court case also hit him badly on a career front – record companies became afraid of him, plugging his records less, tangling him up in business affairs instead of music just as his career was gaining momentum and Gilbert’s record sales fell drastically. The story has a happy ending though – Gilbert is now back in regular touch with Mills’ widow and daughter, the pair being seen backstage at Gilbert’s last concert tour.  


4)    Roger Waters vs David Gilmour, Nick Mason and Rick Wright (1985) Difficulty: Whether the band were entitled to still use the same name after Waters had left the group. Verdict: Despite Rogers’ increasing dominance of the group in the 1970s, the decision was given unanimously in Gilmour and co’s favour – justifiably in Gilmour’s eyes, on a legal technicality in Waters’. Pink Floyd fans know how dark and ugly the band story got in the 1980s: Roger had kicked Rick out of the band, sidelined Dave and Nick and then in 1984 quit the band claiming that Floyd as a band were ‘dead’. Dave and Nick (no, not our beloved coalition partners!) weren’t prepared to retire against their wishes, though, and fought on, rejecting Waters’ claims that without him in the band they were no longer legitimate. There was a secondary factor in the case too: Floyd albums were getting further and further apart in the 1980s (back when four years between albums was still pretty unusual) and Roger was arguing that having failed to deliver on their EMI contract this proved that the band no longer existed anyway. This impasse led to a Roger Waters band touring the same venues as one using the Pink Floyd name, with Gilmour and Mason hiring a whole catalogue of lawyers at every stop along the way in case Roger tried to force their hand with a legal dispute there and then. As it happened, the court case got peculiar: nowhere in the band’s history had any of the band actually signed to a contract using that name – so the courts ruled that they couldn’t disband something that technically didn’t exist. In addition, manager Steve O’Rourke found himself being forced to take sides and – forced legally to inform the others about Roger’s decisions – found himself ousted by Waters. The whole charade went on for years but by 1987 the three-man Floyd (with Rick back in the band) were free to play. This story too has a happy ending – after several snide remarks from both halves of the band in print over the years and a non-appearance at the rock and roll hall of fame, all four men got back together on stage again for Live 8 and nowadays get on better than they have since the early 70s.

5)    Neil Young vs David Geffen (1986) Difficulty: Neil Young’s decisions to make albums ‘that didn’t sound anything like Neil Young’ Verdict:Court case dropped when Neil leaves the label. What’s the worst thing a record label can do to their money-making star? Well, if you’re Elvis they keep re-issuing 20 minute sets of outtakes and skimpy film soundtracks in your name long after your death, if you’re The Kinks they all but ignore your records and drop you from the label at the first chance they get, if you’re The Beach Boys they withhold royalties – and if you’re Neil Young, they sue you for being ‘weird’. Now, David Geffen was a big friend of Neil’s in the 1970s and should have known better what was coming: there’s never ever been two albums in the Neil Young catalogue that share anything more than miniscule DNA with each other and there’s certainly never been a ‘trend’. So when Geffen (the former boss of Asylum Records) began to complain about Neil’s choice of styles (rockabilly, country, hard rock, blues, electronica, you name it Neil did it) it struck us fans as being a bit strange as Neil was surely just being Neil. However, in Geffen’s defence his brand new record label desperately needed the funds: he spent most of his money enticing John Lennon out of retirement and only got one album from him (‘Double Fantasy’) before his untimely death. Neil was his next big star name – but the Neil Young of the 1980s sold far less records than he had in the early 70s. Add in the fact that Neil was distracted in this period – he revealed later that his son Ben was born with cerebral palsy and needed constant care, leaving him little time to make music, a fact he never told Geffen who might have understood his music better – and this was a re4cipe doomed to disaster, with such hilarious results as Neil being ‘ordered’ to make rock music like he used to (he turned in a 20 minute album of 1950s covers instead) and Neil’s threat that, to see out his contract, he might well have to resort to recording 15 different versions of ‘My Way’ in retaliation. The case was closed after Neil’s contract came to an end in 1987, leaving him free to return to his old home at Reprise. 

A NOW COMPLETE List Of Top Five/Top Ten/TOP TWENTY  Entries 2008-2019
1) Chronic Fatigue songs

2) Songs For The Face Of Bo

3) Credit Crunch Songs

4) Songs For The Autumn

5) National Wombat Week

6) AAA Box Sets

7) Virus Songs

8) Worst AAA-Related DVDs

9) Self-Punctuating Superstar Classics

10) Ways To Know You Have Turned Into A Collector

11) Political Songs

12) Totally Bonkers Concept Albums

13) Celebrating 40 Years Of The Beatles' White Album

14) Still Celebrating 40 Years Of The Beatles' White Album

15) AAA Existential Questions

16) Releases Of The Year 2008

17) Top AAA Xmas Songs

18) Notable AAA Gigs

19) All things '20' related for our 20th issue

20) Romantic odes for Valentine's Day

21) Hollies B sides

22) 'Other' BBC Session Albums

23) Beach Boys Rarities Still Not Available On CD

24) Songs John, Paul and George wrote for Ringo's solo albums

25) 5 of the Best Rock 'n' Roll Tracks From The Pre-Beatles Era

26) AAA Autobiographies

27) Rolling Stones B-sides

28) Beatles B-Sides

29) The lllloooonnngggeesssttt AAA songs of all time

30) Kinks B-Sides

31) Abandoned CSNY projects 'wasted on the way'

32) Best AAA Rarities and Outtakes Sets

33) News We've Missed While We've Been Away

34) Birthday Songs for our 1st Anniversary

35) Brightest Album Covers

36) Biggest Recorded Arguments

37) Songs About Superheroes

38) AAA TV Networks That Should Exist

39) AAA Woodtsock Moments

40) Top Moments Of The Past Year As Voted For By Readers

41) Music Segues

42) AAA Foreign Language Songs

43) 'Other' Groups In Need Of Re-Mastering

44) The Kinks Preservation Rock Opera - Was It Really About The Forthcoming UK General Election?

45) Mono and Stereo Mixes - Biggest Differences

46) Weirdest Things To Do When A Band Member Leaves

47) Video Clips Exclusive To Youtube (#1)

48) Top AAA Releases Of 2009

49) Songs About Trains

50) Songs about Winter

51) Songs about astrology plus horoscopes for selected AAA members

52) The Worst Five Groups Ever!

53) The Most Over-Rated AAA Albums

54) Top AAA Rarities Exclusive To EPs

55) Random Recent Purchases (#1)

56) AAA Party Political Slogans

57) Songs To Celebrate 'Rock Sunday'

58) Strange But True (?) AAA Ghost Stories

59) AAA Artists In Song

60) Songs About Dogs

61) Sunshiney Songs

62) The AAA Staff Play Their Own Version Of Monoploy/Mornington Crescent!

63) What 'Other' British Invasion DVDs We'd Like To See

64) What We Want To Place In Our AAA Time Capsule

65) AAA Conspiracy Theroies

66) Weirdest Things To Do Before - And After - Becoming A Star

67) Songs To Tweet To

68) Greatest Ever AAA Solos

69) John Lennon Musical Tributes

70) Songs For Halloween

71) Earliest Examples Of Psychedelia

72) Purely Instrumental Albums

73) AAA Utopias

74) AAA Imaginary Bands

75) Unexpected AAA Cover Versions

76) Top Releases of 2010

77) Songs About Snow

78) Predictions For 2011

79) AAA Fugitives

80) AAA Home Towns

81) The Biggest Non-Musical Influences On The 1960s

82) AAA Groups Covering Other AAA Groups

83) Strange Censorship Decisions

84) AAA Albums Still Unreleased on CD

85) Random Recent Purchases (#2)

86) Top AAA Music Videos

87) 30 Day Facebook Music Challenge

88) AAA Documentaries

89) Unfinished and 'Lost' AAA Albums

90) Strangest AAA Album Covers

91) AAA Performers Live From Mars (!)

92) Songs Including The Number '100' for our 100th Issue

93) Most Songs Recorded In A Single Day

94) Most Revealing AAA Interviews

95) Top 10 Pre-Fame Recordings

96) The Shortest And Longest AAA Albums

97) The AAA Allstars Ultimate Band Line-Up

98) Top Songs About Sports

99) AAA Conversations With God

100) AAA Managers: The Good, The Bad and the Financially Ugly

101) Unexpected AAA Cameos

102) AAA Words You can Type Into A Caluclator

103) AAA Court Cases

104) Postmodern Songs About Songwriting

105) Biggest Stylistic Leaps Between Albums

106) 20 Reasons Why Cameron Should Go!

107) The AAA Pun-Filled Cookbook

108) Classic Debut Releases

109) Five Uses Of Bird Sound Effects

110) AAA Classic Youtube Clips Part #1

111) Part #2

112) Part #3

113) AAA Facts You Might Not Know

114) The 20 Rarest AAA Records

115) AAA Instrumental Songs

116) Musical Tarot

117) Christmas Carols

118) Top AAA Releases Of 2011

119) AAA Bands In The Beano/The Dandy

120) Top 20 Guitarists #1

121) #2

122) 'Shorty' Nomination Award Questionairre

123) Top Best-Selling AAA Albums

124) AAA Songs Featuring Bagpipes

125) A (Hopefully) Complete List Of AAA Musicians On Twitter

126) Beatles Albums That Might Have Been 1970-74 and 1980

127) DVD/Computer Games We've Just Invented

128) The AAA Albums With The Most Weeks At #1 in the UK

129) The AAA Singles With The Most Weeks At #1 in the UK

130) Lyric Competition (Questions)

131) Top Crooning Classics

132) Funeral Songs

133) AAA Songs For When Your Phone Is On Hold

134) Random Recent Purchases (#3)

135) Lyric Competition (Answers)

136) Bee Gees Songs/AAA Goes Disco!

137) The Best AAA Sleevenotes (And Worst)

138) A Short Precise Of The Years 1962-70

139) More Wacky AAA-Related Films And Their Soundtracks

140) AAA Appearances On Desert Island Discs

141) Songs Exclusive To Live Albums

142) More AAA Songs About Armageddon

What difference does a name make? Arguably not much if you’re already a collector of a certain group, for whom the names on the album sleeves just...

This week’s top ten honours the humble motor car. The death trap on wheels, the metaphor for freedom, the put-down of capitalism, a source of...

This week we’re going to have a look at the 10 AAA singles that spent the most weeks at number on the American chart ‘Billboard’ – and it makes for...

Following on from last issue’s study of the American Billboard charts, here’s a look at which AAA albums spent the most weeks on the chart. The...

There are many dying arts in our modern world: incorruptible politicians, faith that things are going to get better and the ability to make decent...

This week we’ve decided to dedicate our top ten to those unsung heroes of music, the session musicians, whose playing often brings AAA artists (and...

Naturally we hold our AAA bands in high esteem in these articles: after all, without their good taste, intelligence and humanity we’d have nothing to...

What do you do when you’ve left a multi-million selling band and yet you still feel the pull of the road and the tours and the playing to audiences...

‘The ATOS Song’ (You’re Not Fit To Live)’ (Mini-Review) Dear readers, we don’t often feature reviews of singles over albums or musicians who aren’t...

In honour of this week’s review of an album released to cash in on a movie soundtrack (only one of these songs actually appears in ‘Easy Rider’...and...

Hic! Everyone raise a glass to the rock stars of the past and to this week’s feature...songs about alcolholic beverages! Yes that’s right, everything...

154) The human singing voice carries with it a vast array of emotions, thoughts that cannot be expressed in any other way except opening the lungs and...

Everyone has a spiritual home, even if they don’t actually live there. Mine is in a windy, rainy city where the weather is always awful but the...

Having a family does funny things to some musicians, as we’ve already seen in this week’s review (surely the only AAA album actually written around...

Some artists just have no idea what their best work really is. One thing that amazes me as a collector is how consistently excellent many of the...

159) A (Not That) Short Guide To The 15 Best Non-AAA Bands

160) The Greatest AAA Drum Solos (Or Near Solos!)

161) AAA Rock ‘n’ Roll Hall Of Fame Acceptance Speeches

162) AAA Re-Recordings Of Past Songs

163) A Coalition Christmas (A Fairy Tale)

164) AAA Songs About Islands

165) The AAA Review Of The Year 2012

166) The Best AAA Concerts I Attended

167) Tributes To The 10 AAA Stars Who Died The Youngest

168) The First 10 AAA Songs Listed Alphabetically

171) The 10 Best Songs From The Psychedelia Box-Sets ‘Nuggets’ and ‘Nuggets Two’

172) The 20 Most Common Girl’s Names In AAA Song Titles (With Definitions) 

180) First Recordings By Future AAA Stars

185) A Tribute To Storm Thorgerson Via The Five AAA Bands He Worked With

188) Surprise! Celebrating 300 Album Reviews With The Biggest 'Surprises' Of The Past Five Years Of Alan's Album Archives!

190) Comparatively Obscure First Compositions By AAA Stars

193) Evolution Of A Band: Comparing First Lyric With Last Lyric:

200) The Monkees In Relation To Postmodernism (University Dissertation)

202) Carly Simon's 'You're So Vain': Was It About One Of The AAA Crew?

217) AAA 'Christmas Presents' we'd most like to have next year

221) Dr Who and the AAA (Five Musical Links)

222) Five Random Recent Purchases

223) AAA Grammy Nominees

224) Ten AAA songs that are better heard unedited and in full

225) The shortest gaps between AAA albums

226) The longest gaps between AAA albums

227) Top ten AAA drummers

228) Top Ten AAA Singles (In Terms of 'A' and 'B' Sides)

229) The Stories Behind Six AAA Logos

230) AAAAAHHHHHH!!!!!!! The Best Ten AAA Screams

231) An AAA Pack Of Horses

232) AAA Granamas - Sorry, Anagrams!

233) AAA Surnames and Their Meanings

234) 20 Erroneous AAA Album Titles

235) The Best AAA Orchestral Arrangements

236) Top 30 Hilariously Misheard Album Titles/Lyrics

237) Ten controversial AAA sackings - and whether they were right

238) A Critique On Critiquing - In Response To Brian Wilson

239) The Ten MusicianS Who've Played On The Most AAA Albums

240) Thoughts on #CameronMustGo

241) Random Recent Purchases (Kinks/Grateful Dead/Nils Lofgren/Rolling Stones/Hollies) 

242) AAA Christmas Number Ones 

243) AAA Review Of The Year 2014 (Top Releases/Re-issues/Documentaries/DVDs/Books/Songs/ Articles  plus worst releases of the year)

244) Me/CFS Awareness Week 2015

245) Why The Tory 2015 Victory Seems A Little...Suspicious

246) A Plea For Peace and Tolerance After The Attacks on Paris - and Syria

247) AAA Review Of The Year 2015

248) The Fifty Most Read AAA Articles (as of December 31st 2015)

249) The Revised AAA Crossword!

251) Half-A-Dozen Berries Plus One (An AAA Tribute To Chuck Berry)

252) Guest Post: ‘The Skids – Joy’ (1981) by Kenny Brown

254) Guest Post: ‘Supertramp – Some Things Never Change’ by Kenny Brown

255) AAA Review Of The Year 2018

256) AAA Review Of The Year 2019 plus Review Of The Decade 2010-2019

257) Tiermaker

258) #Coronastock

259) #Coronadocstock

No comments:

Post a Comment