Showing posts with label Truckin'. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Truckin'. Show all posts

Monday, 3 June 2013

Grateful Dead "Europe '72" (Album Review)



'High Time - The Alan's Album Archives Guide To The Music Of The Grateful Dead' is available now by clicking here!






GRATEFUL DEAD “EUROPE ‘72”


Cumberland Blues/He’s Gone/One More Saturday Night/Jack Straw//You Win Again/China Cat Sunflower > I Know You Rider//Brown-Eyed Woman/Hurts Me Too/Ramble On Rose//Sugar Magnolia/Mr Charlie/Tennesee Jed//Truckin’/Epilogue//Prelude/ Morning Dew



Dear readers, I am in love. You see I have a new phone (see our corresponding top five this week) only some nine years after buying my last one (which is pretty good for me. At the same time my chronic fatigue has been driving me monkeynuts and I’m barely sleeping at the moment, leaving whole great vast wastelands of the night empty. So it’s the perfect time to have come across ‘DeadCast’, a wonderful little invention that connects to a radio station in San Francisco that does nothing else except play Grateful Dead concerts 24/7. I’ve owned my phone for several weeks now and I must have heard about three full concerts every day, from the glorious technicolour all-singing all-dancing European jaunt of 1972 right through to the ailing Garcia’s last work in 1995 that seems to come in monochrome. I’ve always found that when I get into the Dead’s music I really get into it and can’t listen to (or write) about music the same way – effectively modern jazz played on ‘proper’ instruments, there’s nothing quite as transcendental as a Dead concert when the band are in full swing. Naturally my thoughts have turned towards reviewing them last week while I’m still in the ‘zone’ and although I’ve baulked at writing about all 200 ‘Dick’s Picks’/archive concerts from the Dead canon this live-album-with-new-material is fair game (talking of ‘zones’ I’ve only just discovered the Dead did the music for the Twilight Zone remake of the 1980s – guess what my other obsession this past month has been, albeit the original unbeatable black-and-white epics? There’s a Stephen Stills episode too so expect a ‘top five’ sometime soon...)

As the Dead’s only triple album, ‘Europe ‘72’ is their most comprehensive live record for anyone looking to why Dead concerts were so renowned. It wasn’t so much a tour as a 20th century raid: no less than seven band members, all with families, various road crew, recording engineers in charge of taping the album, secretaries and pr people travelled over along with a hefty amount of equipment (including a 16-track recorder back in the days when such things were rare even for studio recording). Immigration officials seeing that lot coming to play ‘music’, back in the days when European bands could only look on with envy at what their American brethren had, must have been rubbing their hands with glee at the chance to bust half the people and impound most of the equipment. Yet by Dead standards things went off pretty smoothly, helping cement the band’s reputation abroad as a real live band that could survive away from their Haight Ashbury upbringing. It’s a shame, in fact, that the Dead never pulled off any major tour like this again because by most accounts it brought the band together just when they needed it (more on why later) and some of the reviews of that tour were the best the band ever got. Then again, like most things with the Dead, perhaps they were already plenty big enough and didn’t want to get any bigger – the original vinyl edition advertises ‘songbooks’ and ‘t-shirts’ for sale, crass commercialism that seems the antithesis of the Dead (however well Jerry’s ties and ‘Cherry Garcia’ ice cream continues to sell).
Every genre is in here somewhere: heavy rocking, country, folk, blues, psychedelia, plus whatever-the-heck-genre-the-noisy-morass-the-jam-at-the-end-of-Truckin’ represents. The Dead shows off their quiet, reflective, mournful sides and their noisy, stomping rocking sides like never before, taking in short pop ditties and a mammoth jam that, on CD, takes up the whole of two sides of vinyl despite including only two recognisable tracks. There are better Dead live sets out there (‘Live/Dead’ from 1969 is still my favourite, with an opening hour of pure telepathic genius) and others have better material (‘Grateful Dead’ aka ‘Skulls and Roses’ from 1971 features ‘Wharf Rat’, which makes it a masterpiece in my book even if nothing else on the album quite reaches such heights). But ‘Europe ‘72’ is the most rounded and full experience of what it was like to be at a Dead show and why the Dead have a loyal following like no other – the closest fans could get to re-creating the Dead concert they’d just seen in their living room until the band’s dissolution in 1995 and the first in an ongoing series of several hundred archive concert releases. For many fans ‘Europe 72’ is more special than all of these tapes, even if it’s only slightly better than the mean average of all these recordings, simply because it was the first and for 23 years best representative of what it meant to be a Deadhead, highs and lows all lumped together.

The band are in good shape too in 1972, despite two horrendous events which both would have killed off lesser bands. The first is an ongoing management issue: always among the more trusting, passive-aggressive of bands, the Dead swap one difficult manager for another, giving the gig to drummer Mickey Hart’s dad Lenny and then watching in horror as he runs off across the border taking their money with him (Hart Senior is arrested when he tries to go back home a few months later, but the Dead never get their money back). Understandably Mickey, whose only just begun to trust his dad himself after a childhood where he was largely absent, is distraught and leaves the band for three years despite several measures by his colleagues to get him to stay. Thankfully this doesn’t hurt the band as much as you might think. Cutting the band’s drum attack back to one drummer again (like the Dead has been in 1967) doesn’t rob the band though as much as give them new life – founding drummer Billy Kreutzmann never played better than at the 1971-72 shows and some of his performances on this album are exemplary (‘Tennessee Jed’ might be one of the Dead’s most boring songs but Billy’s counter-attack drums are a joy to behold). The money troubles, too, are nothing new for a band who’d only just paid off several thousand dollars worth of debt to their record company in 1969 after albums two and three went a little, err, ‘over budget’ compared to their sales. The second event is more worrying. Keyboardist Pigpen had been growing frailer by the year as a wild childhood spent drinking took its toll and this sadly ends up being Pig’s last project with the band that he put together before his death in mid 1973. Going on tour against Dr’s orders, Pig doesn’t even get much of a chance to say goodbye, with just two vocals and one writing credit on the entire triple record (thankfully he gets another, even greater song on the CD re-issue which does help restore the balance a little). Fans and band alike saw the end coming, but it was no less of a shock when Pig struggled to the end of shows and even though his role in the band had been declining from day one (when the Dead were more or less a blues covers group) his presence in the band was essential, the ‘Earth’ plug the Dead needed to connect them with the ground every time they took off into the stratosphere. His ‘Two Souls In Communion’ really should have made the record, a gorgeous outpouring of bitter regret and self-loathing as lyrical and inventive as anything Garcia and Hunter wrote for the band. Pigpen’s death, at just 27, was a momentous loss; there’s still talk in the Grateful Dead team of putting out a ‘tribute’ to Pig featuring his eight last demo recordings on CD for the first time soon – if they’re up to this song it should be a very special release indeed.

As well as re-instating Kreutzmann as the lean, mean lone drummer the Dead deserved in this period, the band have another thing going for them in this period in the shape of Keith Godchaux, the band’s new keyboardist who joined on the 1971 tour but really comes into his own here. Fans have argued about Keith’s merits and worth ever since he joined; my feeling is that he’s perfect for the groovy, eclectic band the Dead were in the early to mid 70s when his light and flowery touches offer such a contrast to Pigpen’s earthly organ swell they take the band in different directions simultaneously; without Pigpen there and on the band’s harder-edged and more commercial late 70s material he often sounds a little lost. Along with the studio ‘Wake Of The Flood’ this album is Keith’s greatest moment with the Dead, turning ‘Tennessee Jed’ into a Wild Western slice of fun, soaring away in a marvellous simplistic solo in the rocky ‘Sugar Magnolia’ and making ‘He’s Gone’ sound like it’s a song in mourning about much more than the loss of some money and a manager. Shy and self-effacing, Keith couldn’t have been less like Pigpen (or Pigpen’s persona anyway) but his telepathy with Garcia in particular in this period is spot-on and must have been a huge sigh of relief for a band who needed to read each other at a split second’s notice. Keith also brought along (or should that be the other way around given that it was she who contacted Garcia about ‘your new piano player’ and wouldn’t take no for an answer?) his wife Donna, a similarly under-rated singer who turns in better performances on Elvis’ late 60s/early 70s singles than the King himself. She never fitted into the band musically as well as her husband, but again her presence in the first few years was welcome, particularly on ‘Sugar Magnolia’ which is transformed from a cute little country song into a hard-rocking duet. Along with ‘Sunrise’, Donna’s gorgeous song from ‘Terrapin Station in 1977, this is her greatest moment with the band and strong enough to help you overlook the occasional off-key squawling in later Dead concerts.

‘Europe ‘72’ is an album of beginnings and endings, then, recorded on a for-the-times whacking great mixing desk that travelled everywhere with the band on their first ever European tour (following a couple of one-off shows in 1970 and 1971). Most of this album was recorded in the UK’s Wembley Stadium (about 18 months before CSNY broke the record for attendance there) and Lyceum London Theatres, with some songs added in from performances in Amsterdam, Paris and Copenhagen. After five years touring America more heavily and more successfully than most bands, a trip to Europe seemed like an ‘adventure’ and the obvious thing to do by a band looking for a new direction – even though, given Pigpen’s ill health and their money troubles it probably wasn’t the wisest thing to do (the band went heavily into debt by bringing such a large touring crew, but successfully gambled on the sales of this record paying off the costs for the tour). While the Dead did tour Europe again (most famously with a show at the Egyptian Pyramids in 1978), it was never on quite the same scale again. As the souvenir of a make-or-break tour ‘Europe ‘72’ is hard to beat, although it’s probably fair to say that this album is also the point when the Dead stop trying to convince the general record-buying public to ‘hop on the bus’ and the band start releasing records with fans in mind instead. As a result this record got wildly differing reviews at the time of it’s release and continues to get them now – one poll I saw about ten years ago had ‘Europe 72’ listed in ‘best live albums’ and ‘greatest triple albums’ (admittedly quite a small category) and number nine on the ‘worst records of all time list’.

Somehow the idea of sitting through two full hours of the Dead, including one formless 40 minute jam has put lots of people off over the years – although as the converted among you will agree, somehow two hours doesn’t seem anything like long enough either to take in all the sights and sounds of a Dead concert. As ever with the Dead there are things that work really really well (a gorgeous floaty ‘Jack Straw’, the sweet-and-sour ‘He’s Gone’, a mammoth rock jam of ‘China Cat Sunflower’ into ‘I Know You Rider’ and a howling, mournful ‘Morning Dew’), things that work out ok if you’re in the right mood because at least no other band is daft/great/unique enough to do them (a 30-minute atonal version of ‘Truckin’ anyone, arguably the simplest and least suitable song in the entire Dead canon for such a coda?) and things that simply do not work (‘Cumberland Blues’ is one of the band’s most irritating songs which doesn’t deserve a second version just two years after the studio original, ‘Ramble On Rose’ and ‘Tennessee Jed’ are among the weakest of Jerry Garcia and Robert Hunter’s usually mighty high quality partnership and three limp country covers would test the patient of a saint (unless he’s Saint Stephen)). To say its hit-and-miss is an understatement: if only the band had spent longer whittling down the selections from the nights when they were really on it this album could have been a masterpiece (a lot of the 1972 shows are either out officially or broadcast on DeadCast; the bonus tracks on the CD re-issue also offer proof of this), as it is it’s merely another Dead near miss.

It’s a shame, too, that circumstances meant that the band were forced to release yet another live album so soon (a year) after their last (a double record this time). Now, before any Deadheads shriek in horror at that sentence let me explain: ‘Grateful Dead’ aka ‘Skulls and Roses’ is another album where original material is sandwiched by (generally weaker or previously released) cover songs – filler material by the usual rock and roll standards, even if traditional storytelling songs like ‘Brown Eyed Women’ are arguably as much of the story as the more modern sounding originals. The band had enough material across these two years to make up a really strong all-original effort: ‘Jack Straw’ ‘Wharf Rat’ ‘Bertha’ ‘Playing In The Band’ ‘He’s Gone’, maybe even a few songs that ended up on Garcia or Bob Weir’s first solo albums or Pigpen’s ‘Two Souls In Communion’ (arguably his greatest song), played at the end of the tour in Germany. Even on the heels of ‘American Beauty’, one of the Dead’s most rounded, mature and popular efforts, this would have made one hell of a follow-up. Hearing the strength of this material spread across what ended up being five different discs on two different records always seemed like a shame, however valuable it was to get the ‘full’ feeling of a Dead concert across on vinyl for the first time. Thankfully the band will go back to the studio and do things properly after this, recording the under-rated ‘Wake Of The Flood’ as a part tribute to Pigpen and part declaration of faith as the band near a decade together – a folky album on these same lines from the ‘Skulls and Roses’/’Europe ‘72’ material would have been delightful. And I’m not the only person to think so either – Robert Hunter even had an idea for the title (‘Ramble On Rose’) and track selection before Garcia sheepishly told him the next batch of compositions would be spread across live double and triple albums. Ah well, even in part, this record still manages plenty of magic while teaching fans the occasional virtues of patience!

I’ve loosely debated here before whether it truly matters where a live album was recorded – apart from sound and clarity, of course. While most AAA live albums have been relegated to our in-depth discussion of live records (see http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2010_09_19_archive.html ), we have covered a few now (mostly for their unique, unissued material) recorded in such disparate places as New York and Leeds (two cities almost the polar opposite of each other...) and here we have another four venues to choose from (five if you count the bonus tracks). The Dead claimed that they could tell the countries they played apart culturally (the German audiences tending to be loudest – the band reckoning the WW2 damage-surrounded Hamburg infusing the spirit of their playing; the Amsterdam audience the most respectful, perhaps because of the sheer history at the Concertgabauw venue the Dead played in), while acknowledging the same fringes of Deadheads at each and every show (the ones trying to climb up on stage partying, those lost in their own musical world and those who’ve come for a natter with friends and a nice day out by the burger van where the music is an added extra). Garcia even added, in one typical insightful rap of the time, that Europe meant ‘order’ whilst America meant ‘chaos’ because ‘it simply hasn’t been around long even to have a form or an order’. What the Dead do here is bring chaos to a slightly muddier, murkier, set-in-its-ways-world and the effect is somehow more staggering than it is in when the Dead play to American audiences, even when heard on a record (the way the band tip to breaking point – and beyond sometimes – seems especially ‘wrong’ in a hall built for revered and rehearsed orchestral performances and all the more thrilling for it!) While I’d never claim to be able to tell which venue is which without looking, there does seem to be some hint of difference in the way the band plays (‘Sugar Magnolia’ and ‘Tennessee Jed’, both recorded here in Paris, are much ‘louder’ and aggressive than the way the band tends to play them throughout the rest of the 1970s; the Lyceum show in contrast sounds meandering and longwinded, even by mid 70s Dead standards). I’d love to know more about who dictated this triple set’s running order and why – hopping about from one song to another, with audience participation mixed down low so you don’t notice the join and with the ‘Weir’ songs stuck together there’s always been something ‘not quite right’ about the jolts from one track top another on this record that even some nifty fades and the natural space where you should be turning the record over can’t hide or explain.

The Dead certainly ‘fitted in’ to Europe much more successfully than Mouse’s hilarious cover artwork attests. While the Dead don’t exactly find the ‘pot of gold at the end of the rainbow’ as featured on the front cover (with one huge boot striding over from the Unites States), they aren’t the hapless, un-co-ordinated and vulgar stereotype American-abroad featured on the back cover either (memorably sticking an ice cream into his head because, well, that was the image Americans had abroad back then. And did again when George Bush was in office). Two of the most striking Dead images not involving skeletons, Mouse got his inspiration after hearing that the band had witnessed an amazing ‘double rainbow’ while on tour – where he got the inspiration for the ‘ice cream’ kid on the back, though, he’s never said!

Overall, then, ‘Europe ‘72’ is a nice souvenir of a milestone tour that captures the Dead at a tipping point in their career, halfway between the ‘rustic Americana’ and Pigpen-based blues of their past and halfway between the slicker, more produced band the Dead become (largely against their will) in the rest of the decade. If you’re new to the Dead and the first thing you hear is the 30 minute jam based around ‘Truckin’ then you have the perfect right to run away screaming and think that this band and everyone who listens to them is mad – but if you hear the album in order and accept it as a record that’s trying to show off every possible side of one of the most complex American bands that’s ever existed, then you’re in for a treat and even the cul-de-sacs and less successful experiments belong here – simply because the Dead were about including everything and no other band would be brave (or foolish – delete where applicable) to let such experiments go through. The Dead aren’t at their peak here and the fact that the ‘new’ songs are outnumbered and to some extent outshone by their old material is a bit of a shame, but given that the Dead are playing in foreign alien lands, with an ailing keyboardist and a new member in tow, whilst suffering from the loss of a drummer and most of the band’s money, ‘Europe ‘72’ isn’t half an impressive artefact. Like most Dead releases but more so, true Deadheads will love it all, casual fans will love bits of it and the rest of the world will just go ‘two hours of country covers and atonal jams – what’s all the fuss about, eh?!’ Frankly, it’s their loss – for anyone whose been touched by the grinning Dead skeleton of fate, we know better and listening to any other music never sounded quite as full, rich and transcendental ever again.


‘Cumberland Blues’ always struck me as a strange choice for the record. Compared to most Dead songs ‘Cumberland’ doesn’t possess the same space for jamming that most other songs on this album do, at the time of release it was only two years since the original had come out (on the ‘Workingman’s Dead’ album) and the song was never quite as popular with Deadheads as the other ‘re-treads’ here such as ‘Morning Dew’ or ‘Sugar Magnolia’. Like many a 1970 Dead song, this is about the struggle of the working classes, this time a miner whose been working so hard he barely has time to see anything of his missus and yet one who fears for his job as so many around him are out of work they would do anything to enjoy even this rotten, hard life. Famously an ex-member of the Cumberland mine told interviewers ‘I wonder what the guy who wrote this song would think if he knew a band like the Grateful Dead would record it?’, a backhanded compliment for composers Garcia, Hunter and Lesh who do a pretty good job at trying to write a traditional protest song. To be fair, this version of the song is light years better than the rather ragged studio original and the instrumental section in the middle is especially good, growling and howling the miner’s pain in a much better realisation of pain than the original, which rather treated the whole thing as a joke. The harmonies are much tighter too, despite being live (a bit of re-recording in the studio perhaps?) and new boy Keith Godchaux is in particular good form, adding a rolling rollicking piano part that wasn’t on the original and brightens the song up tremendously. It has to be said, though, ‘Cumberland Blues’ is too new a song to get a second airing just two years later and despite some improvements this song isn’t different enough to warrant it’s release. Most fans would also plump for almost any other ‘Workingman’s Dead’ over this one too – period performances of ‘High Time’ ‘Dire Wolf’ ‘Black Peter’ or ‘New Speedway Boogie’ from the European tour all deserve a place on the album more. Perhaps the Dead were simply thrilled to be in Britain for (almost) the first time and figured they ought to play one of their most traditional-sounding English folk songs on the tour?

‘He’s Gone’ is a new song and one of the best. Originally the song was Garcia and Hunter’s snarling put-down of Lenny Hart after the band’s manager ran off with all their money and, by Dead standards, the lyrics are harsher than normal (‘Like I told you, what I said, steal your face right off your head!’) However in time the song’s languid, lovely melody and poignant chorus (‘He’s gone – and nothing’s gonna bring him back!’) began to mean an awful lot more to the band, generally played in concert with a ‘deadication’ to someone who’d just died, whether they were in the public eye or part of the Dead’s extended family (for a time in 1973 most performances of ‘He’s Gone’ were for Pigpen). Certainly Garcia’s lush, relaxed melody sounds more like a tribute than a song of condemnation and his guitar-work on this song is particularly strong, with a choked, chunky guitar part that has a gruff sound quite unlike anything else around in 1972. Hunter’s written a better set of lyrics than this occasionally lazy list of metaphors, but as ever there’s much to enjoy from the Dead’s hippy philosopher, especially on the yeaning middle eight that expresses determination that the events won’t get the band down and are just one more worldly obstacle in their quest for spiritual togetherness (‘Lost one round but the price wasn’t anything, just a knife in the back and more of the same’). The Europe ‘72’ version may come early in the song’s incarnation (the Dead performed it right up to their last tour in 1995), but this original is by far the best, the band hitting just the right note of tongue-in-cheek sarcasm and heartfelt sincerity and the harmonies of Garcia, Weir and Lesh wrap around each other smoothly for near enough the last time (Lesh gave up singing for a few years due to throat problems and even afterwards the band never really attempted the sort of close-knit harmonies heard here). One of the highlights of the record and certainly the best new Garcia-Hunter collaboration here.

‘One More Saturday Night’ is a rocking Bob Weir song that was only six months old at the time of release, having appeared on Weir’s first solo album ‘Ace’ in May 1972 (which is effectively the ‘missing’ studio Dead album from 1971-72, seeing as Bobby is backed by the rest of the Dead throughout). In time this song came to be the band’s ‘party’ song, generally appearing either as a rocky set opener or as an upbeat encore after a run of more lyrical performances. Like many a Dead song, this one evolved considerably in time and is already a great deal more powerful and aggressive than the rather timid interpretation heard on ‘Ace’, though not quite as all-out rock as the band’s late 70s and 80s performances of it. The highlight of the song is undoubtedly the guitar interplay between Garcia’s Chuck Berry impressions and Weir’s chunky rhythm, which mesh together in a style closer to the Stones’ work than most Dead songs (being that much younger than the rest of the band and playing rhythm in a band that uses bass as a second melodic part rather than a rhythm one meant Bob hardly ever got the chance to play a ‘normal’ rhythm part and when he does it’s nearly always on songs he wrote himself). The one part that doesn’t quite come off is Godchaux’s flowery piano: while usually bang on the money in these early days this Jerry Lee Lewis style lick doesn’t quite work on what should be a ‘guitar’ song. Empty and silly, with the only really memorable part of the garbled lyric coming when a group of Gods reveal they’ve designed planet Earth not for noble suffering or as a practice for what comes next but simply as a place to party, this song has enough of a groove to be a fine party record. It’s not in the same league as ‘Sugar Magnolia’, though, Bob’s other ‘rocking’ song of the period and the guitarist’s lyrics aren’t quite up to Bob Hunter’s.

Side one, though, might well be Weir’s shining moment with the band (along with the ‘Weather Report Suite’ from 1973). ‘Jack Straw’ is a Hunter lyric about an outlaw named Jack Straw – our UK politicians will know that name better as the name of a labour foreign secretary of the 1990s who might have been born several centuries later but still fits this song’s ‘lovable rogue outlaw’ persona quite well. The real Jack Straw was a British peasant who revolted during the Great Revolt of 1381 which, like most medieval uprisings, was due to excessive taxes. Unusually, there aren’t any more folk stories or poems that have built up around him (despite being quite a notorious figure of his day), so Hunter must have really done his homework on this song! The name is largely forgotten now (except to Dead fans and those who consider Blair’s Labour Party to be ‘outlaws in office’) but the name was passed down to a certain type of English bird (those known as the ‘whitethroat’ or, fittingly, ‘warblers’ which both feature the same distinctive habit of using straw in their nests). Hunter’s lyric is one of his best, with an us-and-them attitude closer to Robin Hood, with the storyteller clearly on the side of the outlaws as the song is given to us in the first person, usually chiding his followers on to be faster. There’s a classic opening verse where the outlaws’ supportive spirit is already stretched to breaking point (‘We can share what we got of yours, because we done shared all of mine!’) and a lyrical description of the almost balletic poise the outlaws have as they ‘hold up’ the rich to fund their lifestyle. Of course, things go wrong and the stakes get higher, Straw recounting how ‘we used to play silver, but now we play for life’ before fleeing from the law on ‘the fourth day of July’. However happy and genuinely well meaning the band of outlaws are, Hunter doesn’t stint from his depictions from the difficulties they face, the song poignantly ending with Straw backtracking to bury his old friends in a ‘shallow grave’ (all he has time to dig) before making one last, less jokey urging to his friend that ‘you’re moving way too slow’. Weir’s music is more than up to the words, though, with a epic melody that builds in intensity every verse and an excellent structure that passes the vocals between himself, Garcia and Lesh, in the true spirit of the ‘sharing’ nature of the lyrics. Garcia’s gentlemanly rogue, in particular, is an excellent performance and Jerry is on the ball throughout the song with some of his best work caught somewhere between urgency and grief. More than one fan has pointed to the similarities between Jack Straw in an un-named past (presumably the 14th century if this really is the ‘Jack Straw’ of legend) and the Grateful Dead in the present; persecuted and hunted despite being a very minor inconvenience to the law. Whether the band intended it or not, they certainly deliver one of their more sympathetic performances here on a piece that’s arguably the best composition and the best performance on the whole triple album. Superb.
Alas ‘You Win Again’ is probably the weakest recording on the album. While some sloppy performances of unsuitable cover songs are part of what the Dead concerts were all about, this one is one of the sloppiest and certainly in a top five of least suitable songs. A hoary hank Williams country song, the song possesses just one verse and not much of a melody so I’m always amazed at how popular it is – and how many people covered this song (Johnny Cash did the best version around of this song, although it’s a moot point whether there can be a ‘best’ version of a song so bad). The Dead haven’t bothered to learn the song, either, starting half-heartedly as the band pick out some notes and Garcia stretching his vocal way past what’s comfortable in a middle eight which, in that key, even Brian Wilson’s falsetto would struggle to nail. The highlight of this song is another surprisingly gruff guitar solo from Garcia that’s over far too soon and Keith Godchaux spoofing some hillbilly honkytonk in his chordal playing in the third repeat of the song’s lone verse. The band will do much better with this song’s ‘loser’ persona on, err, ‘Loser’ among other songs – this narrator is simply too self-pitying to be likeable.

‘China Cat Sunflower > I Know You Rider’ was always one of the band’s more successful live songs, ‘China Cat’ having a stately pounce and distinctive hop that made it naturally recognisable for live performances. China Cat is an incredible song, the sister to Ray Davies’ ‘Phenomenal Cat’ from ‘Village Green Preservation Society’ in 1968 (close enough in time to make me wonder if Garcia and Hunter knew the song firsthand), a daft poetic song about a chesire cat’s mysterious journeys in the night which makes the one from Lewis Carroll’s ‘Alice In Wonderland’ stories seem positively tame. There are millions of great versions of this song out there, but this is one of the better ones, taking the song at a slightly faster lick than the ‘Aoxomoxoa’ original (from 1969). Garcia also knows this complicated nonsense song inside out, now, after several dozen performances compared to the mouthful of the original and the rest of the band have nailed its groove down well, with Godchaux’s piano especially really embellishing the song’s playfulness nicely. The unexpected chord change heading into the instrumental after the second verse is a signpost for some wonderful band interplay too, as Garcia stretches out knowing the rest of the band will catch him if he falls (which he never does). If the original was the Dead at their most psychedelic (with lyrics like ‘copper dome Bodhi drip a silver kimono like a crazy quilt stargown’), then this version is fully in keeping with 1972’s prog rock, stretching the song past it’s natural end and having fun exploring every avenue around the riff. Even for the Dead their interplay in this section is quite terrific and they nail the subtle change into the traditional song ‘I Know You Rider’ much better here than on most performances. While far from the best ye olde folk song the band did, its simple five line-five verse feel is highly fitting for the ‘china cat’ on his long journey crying out to those he’s left behind how ‘you’re gonna miss me when I’m gone’. Fans who want to hear what the original version sounded like should look out for the Byrds compilation ‘Never Before’, where America’s ‘other’ greatest band of the 1960s attempt this song as their long-delayed follow-u[p to the number one ‘Turn! Turn! Turn!’ (which is abandoned when they come up with ‘Eight Miles High’ a few weeks later). Harder rocking and more primitive than the Dead’s version, it’s the missing link between the ‘folk year’ of 1965 and the ‘hard rock psychedelia’ of 1966. The Dead’s version, though, is pretty special too and while I’m not sure if this later recording is actually better than the original it is very very good, especially the addition of an a capella section right at the end of the song.

‘Brown Eyed Women’ is a lesser bar-room epic from Garcia and Hunter, that might have sounded quite nice stripped back to the bare-bones in a studio setting (a la ‘Workingman’s Dead’ or ‘American Beauty’) but sounds a bit rushed and hurried here. While Garcia is as natural as ever, it sounds to me as if the rest of the band simply don’t the know the song that well yet. Lesh’s bass is particularly out of synch with the rest of the band, unusually, peaking during the ‘quiet’ moments and going limp in the ‘busy’ ones. Perhaps that’s because there’s so little here to really remember – the song just sort of ambles along without really doing much until we hit a sudden loud chorus that’s repeated a few too many times for comfort (‘Brown eyed women and red grenadine, the bottle was dusty but the liquor was clean!’) It’s yet another tale of a Jack Jones, working class man down on his luck, this time a bootlegger from the deep South during the depression (interesting that this album should feature two ‘Jacks’ and that this figure should share his name with the butcher from Dad’s Army – which had been running four years at the time this album came out – and in many ways reads like a Bob Hunter character). Unfortunately unlike Hunter’s other sensitive lyrics we don’t get to really learn this character’s ‘story’ – just the results of it, with Jones an alcoholic by the end of the song, so we don’t know quite how sympathetic we’re meant to be with him. At their best Garcia and Hunter were the best storytellers in the business, effortlessly re-creating an America from a hundred years earlier – but on this song inspiration seems to have let them both down.

‘It Hurts Me Too’ is an Elmore James cover that’s pretty awful too. If I was Pigpen I’d have been furious that such a bad performance of a song which the band hardly ever played (and quite honestly haven’t spent that much time learning) was left off the album instead one of my own, superior songs. Admittedly, there was talk at the time of Pig doing his own solo album, in the vein of Jerry’s and Bob’s (released in 1971 and 1972) so he may have been saving material for that – but if that’s true then why is the original ‘Mr Charlie’ on the record? And surely Pig was doing at least half a dozen cover songs at the time better – just listen to the ‘Bear’s Choice’ album (recorded in this era but only released after Pig’s death in 1973) where the rest of the band are a little shabby but Pig positively glows (‘Smokestack Lightning’ at least should have made this album!) Elmore James is famous for his slide guitar (George Harrison references him during ‘For You, Blue’ from the Beatles ‘Let It Be’ album) and the musical highlight here is Garcia trying to interpret that sound within his own characteristic playing, ending up with a hybrid of both on a solo that’s so slow it nearly stops all together. Lyrically this song should be right up Pigpen’s street, with its tale of being abandoned for another man, but the song isn’t right for his intensity or his chemistry, ending up sounding self-pitying instead of vengeful or hurt – it’s best known to modern audiences thanks to an Eric Clapton cover. The song suits him an awful lot better than the Dead. One of the Dead’s all time worst cover songs, this album is really falling apart in the middle...

‘Ramble On Rose’ is a little better, a third Garcia-Hunter song that’s not up to their best work but does at least have a catchy, insistent tune and sweet, if confusing lyrics. We’ve commented before that many of Hunter’s lyrics are based around metaphors, of people feeling something ‘like’ somebody else – well, here’s a whole song of them! In total there’s 10 ‘just likes’ across the song, from storytale children Jack and Jill to Victorian murderer Jack The Ripper (what is it with all the ‘Jacks’ on this album?!) to the lesser known ‘Crazy Otto’ (a German piano player) ‘Billy Sunday’ (a baseball player who turned to religion and helped form the Evangelist Church) and the more generic ‘Wolfman Jack’ (yep, another one!) The chorus is confusing in context, consisting of Garcia asking ‘did you say your name was rambling Rose?’ which doesn’t seem to bear any relation to the rest of the song, although it could be another of Hunter’s alter egos here (if anyone can ramble in a song, it’s him – hence the very clever middle eight ‘I’m gonna sing you a hundred verses in ragtime, I know this song ain’t ever going to end!’) There is an end to the song, though, one which tells us a sort of generic morality tale that ‘the grass ain’t greener, the wine ain’t sweeter, either side of the hill’ – possibly the story that all the characters in this song should have learnt (it’s certainly true for Frankenstein, who finds his world torn upside down when he creates his monster and the biblical tale of Jericho too, though I can’t say Jack The Ripper probably had too many sleepless nights seeing as he was never caught). Lovably daft, but impenetrably written, ‘Ramble On Rose’ sounds like one long in-joke we listeners aren’t really in on and even it’s author admitted in an interview of the time that it was ‘pure whimsy’. Alas, compared to the similarly loveably daft ‘China Cat Sunflower’ Garcia’s melody isn’t quite so memorable and the song isn’t quite as well loved by fans, although it is an improvement over both ‘Brown Eyed Women’ and ‘Tenessee Jed’. By the way, listen out to a funny noise about 4:15 that sounds like someone rubbing a balloon really fast – presumably its a bit of music equipment going awry although perhaps it was one of the many historical characters on this song making themselves known?

‘Sugar Magnolia’ is an old Dead classic and despite being only two years old at the time (it appeared on ‘American Beauty’) it’s already one of the established Dead classics in the set and sounds completely different to the rather timid studio original. Although not quite as butch’ as the muscly late 70s versions (the closest the Dead ever came to heavy rock), it’s obviously a lot more rock and roll than the country-ish studio version. Bob Weir’s lovely set of changes sound tailor made for radio airplay (which this song got a lot of, even though it was never technically released as a single) while Hunter’s corresponding lyric manages to be simpler than normal whilst still suitable for the Dead. Sugar Magnolia sounds like a sister of Neil Young’s Cinnamon Girl’, a good time lass who can brighten up a room with her smile and – in a memorable couplet – knows exactly how to be valuable to the narrator: ‘She takes the wheel when I’m seeing double, pays my ticket when I speed’. A song born for dancing, Magnolia’s riff is as infectious as she is, pretty and easy on the air without being hollow or false. One of those classic rock songs written around some mythical creature of perfection, Magnolia doesn’t seem to put a foot wrong: a ‘summer love’ in ‘spring, fall and winter’, waiting patiently backstage while the narrator ‘sings to you’ (a nice break of the fourth wall there). Famously, Weir didn’t even know what the end of the song was when he began taping his lead vocal, Hunter scribbling the last two verses furiously and thrusting them to the vocal booth during a break (the Dead recorded ‘American Beauty’ on a very tight schedule, although that doesn’t show in the finished album at all). The Dead have played better versions of this song over the years (just listen to Garcia trip over himself at 4:50), but at the time those unlucky enough not to have heard how one of the Dead’s best loved songs had altered when played live were thrilled enough – especially with the coda that extends the song by another two minutes, features a terrific duet with Donna Godchaux and was even played separate to the main song for a time in the 70s (a piece Deadheads logged as ‘Sunshine, Daydream’). Does ‘Sugar Magnolia’ deserve its place on the album less than two years after release? Well, yes and no – it’s not as welcome as new material would have been, but it’s different enough to make its addition to the album worthwhile.

‘Mr Charlie’ is the last of Pigpen’s songs to be released in his lifetime and if you didn’t know his story better you’d assume that this is another wild child who died young singing a jokey song about the drugs that killed him (the band may have denied it a little at the time, given that it was illegal and all, but ‘Mr Charlie’ is a famous acronym for cocaine and a joke that a good percentage of Deadheads would have got). Did anyone tell the famously anti-drug Pigpen, though, who died of liver failure caused by nearly two decades of excessive drinking and never touched drugs his whole life through? What we have here is a song that works against type: Hunter wasn’t really one for drugs either, yet his lyric is as mischievous and eye-winking as any number of similar ‘drug’ songs of the day (from Lennon’s ‘Everybody’s Got Something To Hide Except For Me and My Monkey’ to any number of Stones songs). Despite their reputation for being ‘druggies’, only the Dead’s ‘Casey Jones’ features another reference to a drug, making this a highly unusual lyric (especially in the wake of the band’s bust of 1970 in which Pig was arrested for use, despite not having used a drug in his life ever). One alternative reading is that ‘Mr Charlie’ is also a longstanding term used by black slaves to describe their white masters – given his many links with African Americans (who treated the boozing Pig as one of their own during his teenage years), is this song instead a reference to a slave rebellion (‘Going to scare you up and shoot ya! Mr Charlie told me so!’) It may well be that this is another ‘joke’ song, a pastiche of all the sort of songs Pig usually sings, complete with references to a ‘shotgun’ (which may be literal or may be a drug addict’s needle), money troubles, women troubles and ‘alligator wine’ (‘Alligator’ being one of Pig’s most popular songs). There’s a curious chorus, too, of ‘woolly bully, jooba jooba’ which references both the Sam and the Shams’ one big hit and The Beatles’ ‘I Am The Walrus’. Pig struts his stuff as fine as ever and his tune is everything a Pigpen song should be – strutting with confidence and talking in a conversational, confessional style – but Hunter’s lyric adds a new dimension here. After proving that he, too, could write a Pigpen style song (‘Easy Wind’ from Workingman’s Dead’, a song many fans naturally assumed was written by Pigpen given that he sung it so wholeheartedly), could this be Hunter trying to do a ‘pastiche’ of this material? Is this a joke? And if it is, did Pigpen know? Less impressive than a lot of other Pigpen songs of the time, it’s still preferable to ‘It Hurts Me Too’ and one last welcome glimpse of a terrific singer taken long before he should have been.

‘Tennessee Jed’ is another rather rambling Garcia-Hunter song, one that unusually for this album is sung straight from the point of view of a slave/prisoner (someone with a ball and chain at any rate) being called back to his home city of Tennessee (presumably to answer some legal infringement). Poor Jed is having one hell of a time: a rich man ‘steps on my poor head’ (physically or metaphorically one wonders?), ‘drinks all day and rocks all night’ in an effort to escape his sad existence, has seen his dog kicked by the mysterious Charlie Fog and most worryingly ‘drops four flights and cracked my spine’. Presumably this is another of Hunter’s narrators prone to exaggeration (the only way Jed could possibly get to Tennessee with a broken spine is inside an ambulance), but it’s hard to get any real for him or his story. Garcia’s melody fittingly sounds like a dog with a limp, awkwardly moving forward a step at a time, but accurate as this musical picture is ‘Jed’ is quite a difficult song to listen to. The band try their best to jam out on it during the end of the piece, but only Garcia sounds comfortable with the limping time signature and the whole piece is in danger of falling part long before the end, with the whole of the Dead seemingly playing in different keys to each other. A song that reads better than it sounds, ‘Tennessee Jed’ is a song that needed more work and rehearsal and notably didn’t hang around in the Dead’s setlists for very long.

‘Truckin’ is another famous Weir-Hunter song from ‘American Beauty’ that had gone down a storm with audiences, although to the best of my knowledge Weir’s opening claim that ‘this is a number that made number one in California’ isn’t strictly true (again, this was a big radio hit but was never technically a single – there only ever was one bona fide Dead hit single and that won’t be till 1987!) Every line in the song is real and, for a time, the band intended to add an extra verse for each big event in their lives – sadly an idea that never came to fruit (ahem, here’s my go for 1972: We went over to play in Europe, Pig was looking sick as a dog, along the way with the crowds we found true love, but I have to tell you – losing all that money made it quite a slog’. Or 1977: ‘We got right off at Terrapin Station, ‘cause things weren’t looking too groovy, but after an 18 months hiatus we’re back again, promoting the Grateful Dead Movie!’ Or how about 1979?: ‘Godchaux go and God bless you, we’ve hired a keyboardist by the name of Brent, we’ve outlived the years we sang about on ‘Morning Dew’, and out next direction is ‘Heaven’ sent’. OK, I’ll stop now, I promise). The band may have only been going five years at the time the song was written but they’d already been through so much in that time that the chorus ‘what a long strange trip it’s been!’ already sounds hard fought for. The thin line between getting it right and wrong every night also led to one of the best Dead lines ever ‘sometimes the light’s all shining on me – and other times I can barely see!’ Weir’s melody has a swagger and informal feel to it that’s a dream for Hunter to fit lyrics to, while the song’s clever riff means that Garcia and Weir’s guitars are at odds with Lesh’s bass throughout, raising and falling in tandem like a giant musical see-saw, perfectly suiting the ups and downs of life in the lyrics. The studio original is laidback, funky confessional – the Europe ’72 version starts the same way (albeit with a more laidback, less urgent strut) but soon develops at around the five minute mark into an epic launchpad for one of the longest jams in the band’s history. Unusually Weir takes charge of where the song goes rather than Garcia (this is ‘his’ song I suppose), putting in some excellent chunky chord work before the band slowly back off and it’s Keith Godchaux’s piano that’s filling in the spaces with a floral decoration Eventually this version of the song clocks in at 13 minutes and is still just about recognisable as ‘Truckin’ when the song slowly mutates into next track ‘Epilogue’. Personally, I rate other period jam sessions based around this song more: the band sound like they’re reeling off the ‘song’ a bit too quickly in their haste to get to the jamming bit and there’s a large chunk of four or so minutes where not much is happening. Still, few bands can improvise as well as the Dead on a good day and this is at least close to the experience of being at a real Dead concert.

‘Epilogue’ itself is pushing it a bit though: five whole minutes of noodling which gradually gets further and further away from the ‘Truckin’ riff. In many ways this is the first ‘official’ appearance of ‘Space’ on record – the part of the show the Dead always gave over to experimenting and letting jams drift in any direction. Some versions of ‘Space’ can be hallucinatory – not the kind of music you’d want to listen to every day, but the sound of five or six people going someplace new instantaneously and offering new music you’d never hear outside this environment that shapes the way you hear all formed, categorised music thereafter. Some versions of ‘Space’ are a mess, with five or six people going in different directions all at the same time so that you end up tied up in knots rather than in some destination you wanted to go into. Sadly, while not the worst jame on tape, this ‘Epilogue’ is closer to the latter, Keith’s criss-crossing chords and Phil’s bass seemingly in another dimension to what’s actually quite a good am going on between Jerry and Bobby. Things do pick up slightly when the tempo gains a bit of speed at the 3:45 mark, but the opening three minutes are among the heaviest going of all ‘official ‘ lifetime’ Dead releases. The song also collapses completely around 4:30, just when Jerry’s finally picked out a pretty good four note riff that could have been the basis for a much more interesting jam.

Things continue with ‘Prelude’ (trust the Dead to do things backwards, although to be fair this is where the split between records five and six on the vinyl original occurred), a similarly formless jam that’s closer in spirit to modern jazz than anything else on the record. Keith, Jerry and Bobby are picking out the same three notes over and over again really fast while Billy’s drumming gets even more eccentric than Boris Johnson and the band are heading for a complete breakdown by the time we hit the seven minute mark. Frankly it would all be unlistenable had all this chaos and confusion not been leading up to...

One of the Dead’s greatest versions of one of their greatest cover songs ‘Morning Dew’. Like most of the tracks that appeared on the Dead’s first eponymous album in 1967, it never really got a proper hearing originally: a combination of nerves and a sudden craze for ‘upper’ speed tablets meant every song was played reallyreallyeversofastgoshwow and this gorgeous song in particular always deserved a second go. Rising from the noisy ashes of ‘Prelude’, this post-apocalyptic ballad sounds especially apt, Garcia starting in a whisper and building up to a searing, heartbreaking climax some eleven minutes later. Composers Bonnie Dobson and Tim Rose wrote the song after watching the moving Gregory Peck film ‘On The Beach’, where the cold war turns hot and everybody except the inhabitants of an American submarine dies. The song’s long, drawn out rhetorical questions are the perfect hippie response to a world full of war and opposition for no visible purpose and while the song looks empty on paper, it sounds perfect when wrapped around Garcia’s gentle, fragile voice and gossamer light melody. Again, there are better versions of ‘Morning Dew’ around (including a particularly good one from Hollywood in 1971, which we’ll be discussing in more depth next week) and this song – by no means the most regular in the Dead’s setlist in 1972 – sounds a little under-rehearsed, with the band crashing notes and missing fills. All that said, the very human-ness of this version makes a lot of sense and by slowing down the tempo considerably the band get far closer to the heart of this song than they ever did in 1967. It takes a wild and hairy, surprisingly guttural solo from Weir to really breathe life into the song, though, and even that only occurs some ten minutes in. Anyone who wants to hear what the original sounded like should keep an eye to the ground for fellow AAA artists Lulu’s nosier, punchier version from 1967 (the same year as the Dead’s original) which I am also highly fond of. I wouldn’t say it quite makes sitting through the last 30-odd minutes worthwhile, but it does sound particularly revelatory and inspiring after so much noise and mess.

So, then, what to make of an album that on the one hand was cobbled together in a hurry to give the band some money and yet on the other hand is much longer (and at the time expensive) than all other live albums out on the market at the time except the multi-artist ‘Woodstock’? ‘Europe ‘72’ has much to offer the obsessive Grateful Dead fan - which by and large most Deadheads tend to be, as it’s hard to only partly like this band - especially at the time, before the huge great seas of bootlegged concerts began to appear officially in the post-Garcia world of the 1990s and 00s when the band were no more and fans could pick and choose their favourite versions of particular songs (which is exactly what I shall be doing next week, before the Dead trance I’m in works its way out of my system). In 1972 this album and the similar-but-smaller-and-somehow-lesser sister album ‘Skulls and Roses’ were the closest thing Dead fans had to a souvenir of the live show they’d just seen, where the band could turn on a knife-edge in any direction on a whim. Frankly, some of these whims simply don’t work and I do question either the taste or the workload of the person responsible for choosing the best songs because, frankly, there are better versions of these songs out there even taken from the same dozen or shows that were recorded especially for this album. But then, what critics often forget is that ‘Europe ‘72’ was certainly not designed to be the best live album around (the band would hardly have turned their best known song on the album into an often unlistenable 30 minute jam if they had), it was simply meant to showcase the highs and lows, thrills and spills of what life was like in the band. To this end they succeeded, offering a brave and eclectic selection of songs that only fail from seeming like a ‘real’ Grateful Dead concert in that the sum is much lesser than the parts. Usually a whole Dead show (and I speak this as one born too young to experience them first hand, but as a ‘taper’ whose studied hundreds now) is revelatory by the end if heard in the right way, with even the weakest songs sounding more interesting for the way it’s played and the context of what it comes between. Whether because of speed, naivety or an unwillingness to go through the tapes or select one good concert (even one per each of the three LPs would have done) ‘Europe ‘72’ doesn’t do this and so ends up being a rather lesser and lesser loved beast than the fabulous ‘Live/Dead’ (which is largely from just two shows), if better than later, more watered down shows to come (‘Reckoning’ and ‘Without A Net’, although I have a soft spot for ‘Dead Set’ and would put it on a par with this one). Basically there’s an exception to every rule at work here: the new material isn’t always top notch by Dead standards (though the best of it, like ‘Jack Straw’ and ‘He’s Gone’, most certainly is), the ‘old’ songs aren’t that different (although ‘Sugar Magnolia’ and ‘China Cat Sunflower’ most definitely are), the selection of old favourites aren’t necessarily what everyone would want or expect from a Dead show (although ‘Truckin’ is) and the cover versions are often flimsy and flat (although ‘Morning Dew’ is the perfect choice).

It’s a pic-and-mix Grateful Dead style, with all the hit-and-miss qualities you’d expect. It could easily have been one wonderful single LP without losing too much of its essence (our AAA altered line-up: ‘Sugar Magnolia’ ‘Jack Straw’ ‘China Cat Sunflower’ ‘I Know You Rider’ ‘He’s Gone’ ‘Ramble On Rose’ ‘Truckin’ (with early fade) and ‘Morning Dew’). That said it could also have been a stupendous box set with a good three hours’ worth of excellent material from the same shows that deserve to have made the album more than what’s actually here (‘Two Souls In Communion’ for starters, another Pigpen song ‘Chinatown Shuffle’ that oddly was included on the 1990 CD re-issue of this album but not the 2000-era one – no great loss but it’s better than ‘Hurts Me Too’ that’s for sure, Garcia’s solo songs ‘Loser’ ‘The Wheel’ and ‘Deal’ and period versions of such Dead songs ‘Cold Rain and Snow’ ‘Viola Lee Blues’ ‘Dupree Diamond Blues’ ‘Cosmic Charlie’ ‘Black Peter’ ‘Dire Wolf’ (very different with Weir singing lead), ‘New Speedway Boogie’ ‘Uncle John’s Band’ ‘Casey Jones’ ‘Brokedown Palace’ ‘Ripple’ ‘Candyman’ and ‘Friend Of The Devil’ all semi-regulars in the band’s setlists of 1972 and not yet featured on any live album). In truth, ‘Europe ‘72’ isn’t an album in it’s own right anyway, more a snapshot of the Dead on a particular day (or to be specific five days) in a watershed year, with the ‘boot’ on the cover between the two rainbows perhaps also signifying the step between the ‘old’ and the ‘new’. Come 1973 the band will have their own record company, a new studio bound record far more graceful and luscious than anything the band do here and Pigpen will be gone. You sense that somewhere behind this album’s promise of a great exciting journey to pastures new is a sad band waving goodbye to ‘stage one’ in their career as worries about stage two (with counterfeit albums, a tiring film production schedule and an unexpected 18 month hiatus in just two years’ time) are also in their thoughts. Give or take the ‘Bear’s Choice’ tribute to Pigpen (released in 1973), the first Grateful Dead box set (‘The Golden Road 1965-72’) sensibly ends here at the exact midway point of the band’s discography, although thematically ‘Europe ‘72’ should have come separately (perhaps with one disc on each?), perfectly splitting the eras in half. A stepping stone to greater things from a direction that had already seen many great things, there are few records you can buy that will take you on as many journeys as ‘Europe ‘72’ – and most of those journeys take you much further afield than Europe. A flawed, but endlessly fascinating LP. 6/10




‘Live/Dead’ (1969) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/05/grateful-dead-livedead-1969.html

'Workingman's Dead' (1970)
http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2012/03/news-views-and-music-issue-138-grateful.html

'American Beauty' (1970)
http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2008/07/review-40-grateful-dead-american-beauty.html
'Blues For Allah' (1975) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/03/grateful-dead-blues-for-allah-1975.html

'Terrapin Station' (1977)
http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2010/08/news-views-and-music-issue-72-grateful.html
'Shakedown Street' (1978) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2016/04/grateful-dead-shakedown-street-1978.html
'Go To Heaven' (1980) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2014/09/grateful-dead-go-to-heaven-1980-album.html
'In The Dark' (1987) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com/2013/12/grateful-dead-in-dark-album-review.html

'Built To Last' (1989)
http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2008/10/news-views-and-music-issue-7-grateful.html
Surviving TV Clips 1966-1994 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-surviving-tv-clips-1967.html
The Best Unreleased Recordings 1966-1993 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-best-unreleased.html
The Last Unfinished Album 1990-1995 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-last-unfinished-album.html
Live/Solo/Compilations Part One 1966-1976 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-official.html
Live/Solo/Compilations Part Two 1978-2011 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-official_29.html
A Guide To The CD Bonus Tracks http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/07/grateful-dead-guide-to-cd-bonus-tracks.html
Dick's Picks/Dave's Picks http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/07/grateful-dead-dicks-picksdaves-picks.html
Road Trips/Download Series/Miscellaneous Archive Releases
http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/07/grateful-dead-road-tripsdownload.html

Essay: Why The ‘Dead’ Made Fans Feel So ‘Alive’ https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2018/01/grateful-dead-essay-why-dead-makes-fans.html
Five Landmark Concerts and Three Key Cover Versions https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2018/03/grateful-dead-five-landmark-concerts.html


Friday, 4 July 2008

Grateful Dead "American Beauty" (1970) (Revised Review 2015; Originally 'Core' Review #40)




'High Time - The Alan's Album Archives Guide To The Music Of The Grateful Dead' is available to buy now by clicking here!







Grateful Dead "American Beauty" (1970)


On which the Dead celebrate Americana with their most beautiful record…



Track Listing: Box Of Rain/ Friend Of The Devil/Sugar Magnolia/ Operator/ Candyman// Ripple/ Brokedown Palace/ Till The Morning Comes/ Attics Of My Life/ Truckin’ (UK and US tracklisting) 

"Some forty-five years on and everything you know is aging, lost my spare teeth and they say I don't have any more bite, but you know what it's like in a world where everything's perpetually changing, your old age can't help feeling wrong when your youth it got things so right, sometimes the lights still shine all the day, especially when we're reviewed by the AAA, we never again had quite so much to say, except that - hey - what a long strange trip it's been..."

(Missing verse from parallel world versions of 'Truckin' as recorded by a still-touring Grateful Dead in 2015. The song's running to some 45 verse by now and takes an hour and a half to play!)

LONG haired psychedelic weirdoes they may have been, but the Dead still knew how to tell a concise, moving story in a three-minute pop song. The difference is that up till now the Dead haven't had to - the excitement has all been about the songs and ringing the most out of them  but as the sixties turned to the seventies and a more mellow laidback approach was the order of the day the Dead were at the crest of that wave too. American Beauty is probably the Dead’s most popular album full of several of their most popular songs, but interestingly it's also the most atypical to their traditional image, being a harmony-laden, easygoing moving masterpiece that brought a whole new dimension to the band’s already multi-pronged sound. To some extent this album and its predecessor Workingman’s Dead is a compromise, a chance to record an album quickly and hassle free that would appeal to American radio and help reduce the monstrous debts the Dead owed Warner Bros without scaring off too many long-term fans. Yet it's not as cynical an album as that makes it sound, because this is not in any way, shape or form the Dead’s most conservative album: the band confront several taboo subjects head on in their tightly packed lyrical songs, with thoughts about death, passing time and bad karma catching up with you with a maturity way beyond their years. Many critics would claim that the Dead simply discovered discipline, working these songs over and over until they were pared back to their essence. However for me the biggest change, as hinted in the title, is that the Dead have discovered beauty for the first time after years of writing about the more turbulent side of life: no one listening to the fevered frightening nightmare of 'St Stephen' or the bouncy jolly ride of 'China Cat Sunflower' could have guessed that a song as accepting and brilliantly pretty as 'Attics Of My Life' was round the corner.

There's a tale that nervous Warner Brothers executives listened back to this album in shock, amazed that the Dead could sound this good (and marketable!), nervously waiting till the end to see if the band would throw them a curve-ball at the end. Instead the Dead even went to the trouble of doing their job for them, putting the most marketable songs at the beginning and ends of the sides where busy disc-jockeys could 'find' them. To give them their dues, the record label played their part too and pushed this album in most of the right places, enabling people who'd either never heard of the Dead or long assumed they weren't their cup of tea to give them another go. Whilst still not that strong a seller (only in 1987 will the Dead come close to getting anything close to what most bands would consider a 'mainstream hit') 'American Beauty' fulfilled everything that could be asked of it: the record rekindled interest in the band, proved that there was more to them than feedback and thirty minute suites and it paid off all their debt. In many respects it's almost a shame that the album was quite as successful as it was - a couple more low-key on-the-cheap beauties like this one in the Dead catalogue and I doubt many fans would be complaining!

Immediately when you play this record you know that something has changed, even compared to stepping stone 'Workingman's Dead'. The performances are tighter, the songs more accessible, the whole somehow more beautiful than before. That's especially true of the vocals, with the Dead borrowing heavily from their friends in Crosby, Stills and Nash for a sound that's somehow very much of the time (lots of West Coast bands were doing this sort of thing in the early 70s) and yet still very distinctively Dead. For a start the three voices don't do what you'd expect: in every band from CSN on down Garcia's pretty high-pitched voice would be the top harmony; here he's the lead. Bobby, with the most commercial and middle pitched voice would normally be in the middle - but he's on the bottom (even when he sings lead on 'Truckin' and 'Magnolia' the choruses go back to this arrangement). Phil has the deepest natural voice, but he's on top with some alarming falsetto work that's awfully good (sadly he'll all but give up singing after this album, with 'Box Of Rain' his first and last lead vocal for the band until 1974). However the Dead are in perfect harmony with each other in far more ways than just vocally: the explosive telepathic runs of 1968-69 notwithstanding, this may still be the best performance the band ever gave in the studio, covering each other magnificently throughout this album’s surprisingly complex vocal twists and turns. All the band get showcases of sorts across the record and while Jerry is still very much the man with most of the ideas in this period this is far more of a 'band' record than 'Workingman's. While many critics compared the Dead's 'new' style to CSN and The Band they're actually wrong in one sense - CSN was all about how three very different voices could unite when they shared the same goal; 'The Band' too had various increasingly cynical takes on modern-day American living. By contrast the Dead all seem to be after the same things - namely peace, love and understanding - and only Pigpen's 'Operator' stands out on an album notably similar throughout in feel (it helps that Garcia's writing partner Bob Hunter wrote all the lyrics except that song, including the Lesh and two Weir songs for the one and only time).

The other major development is Garcia's new purchase of a pedal steel. Whilst he'll soon get tired of his toy and had already made a name when using it on sessions outside the band (CSNY's 'Teach Your Children' being the most famous example) it's here where Garcia will use it most. Sounding more like his fragile and thin but courageously gritty vocals than his more quick-flying electric guitar spins, the pedal steel really give flavour and atmosphere to this album, coating every song with a sense of nostalgia, tradition and melancholy. Jerry uses the instrument sparingly across this album - even the rock powerhouses like 'Magnolia and 'Truckin' don't actually have much of a solo on the studio versions - but the pedal steel is used often and well, especially the lengthy solo in the middle of 'Candyman' that's positively heartbreaking and may well be the best of his many jaw-droppingly spot-on solos in this book (hinting at everything the narrator has given up to score their next 'fix', of whatever it is they're fixed on). Elsewhere the other memorable addition to the band's bag of sounds comes in the shape of Dave Nelson, a comrade from New Riders Of The Purple Sage (a kind of countryfied version of the Dead with whom both Jerry and Mickey frequently guested) who plays some delightful mandolin on 'Ripple' and 'Friend Of The Devil' (a song that was initially given to New Riders before the Dead 'pinched' it - a demo with a slowed down pure country arrangement survives but sadly hasn't been released yet). All these extra sounds cut back on what the Dead were known for - guitar bass and two lots of drums - and Pigpen's ailing health and the loss of Tom Constanten mean there's less keyboards on this album than usual too (although session musician and AAA regular Nicky Hopkins plays some lovely choppy chords on 'Candyman' again).

Thankfully these sounds weren't mere gimmicks - the Dead most certainly had the songs to go with them. Garcia and Hunter had been heading towards the lyrical, dramatic, visually precise material on this album for several years now and the strong reception given to 'Workingman's Dead' has clearly invigorated them. Partly because of the debt still hanging over their head from 'Aoxomoxoa' but mainly because the songs came at speed, the Dead were back in the studio almost straight away and wrote, recorded and mixed this album within the space of a couple of months - a ridiculously speedy response. What's staggering is that the album is strong enough to build on even a promise as great as 'Workingman's, with Garcia and Hunter on the roll of a lifetime that will make this album their most consistent (with only 'Till The Morning Comes' under-par). Old college friends unexpectedly re-united in 1968, Garcia and Hunter are the perfect foils for each other on this album and their words and music fit together so well throughout this album that they might well have been by the same person. The two certainly had a greater writing bond than most pairings. They were living in the same house during this period, with Garcia choosing to flat-share while still trying to pay off his share of the Dead’s debts to Warner Brothers after three flop albums in a row at the beginning of their career. Garcia, downstairs, would often practise his guitar licks and play around with chords while Hunter upstairs would hear the songs through the thin floor of his room and occasionally be inspired by Garcia’s improvising enough to write, with the two often working on the same ‘song’ without the other knowing till they met up the next morning. So well does this arrangement work that you wonder why they ever moved out - or why the Deadhead community didn't build them their own millionaire's cottage so they could work together forevermore.  

Hunter’s words are more like poetry than lyrics and are never better than on this album, fitting Garcia, Lesh and Weir’s vocal characters snugly while offering Hunter’s own delightful poetic take on the universe in addition. Both narrow in its autobiographical scope (never has the history of a band been so comical yet moving as it has in Truckin’) and wide in its subject matter (Box Of Rain covers the grim reaper awaiting us all with unbearable poignancy and there are also debates about religion and mankind’s spiritual journey on Ripple and Attics Of My Life), American Beauty covers a staggering amount of ground. There's little on the surface that seems to unite these songs either - compared to earlier and later Dead albums that are all bases around a 'theme' - but after getting to know this record well I do see a theme of 'faith' cropping up. 'Box Of Rain' tries to find words of comfort in a situation where none can really be found and yet finds the right words anyway, simply by virtue of facing the darker side of life head-on in the hope that further down the road there will be an answer, that 'the sun will be shining and birds will be singing' and even this hardship will pass. 'Operator' and 'Sugar Magnolia' are love songs based around faith - the former is a Pigpen song about his faith that all will be well if only the narrator's crush will answer her bleeding phone, while the latter is a Weir song about how the narrator has come to rely so much on his partner being there whenever he needs her ('Takes the wheel when I'm seeing double, pays my ticket when I speed!') 'Candyman' is an addiction to...something (Drugs? Women? Booze?) based around the rather misguided idea that the drug dealer will always be around when the narrator calls. 'Ripple' goes to some very strange places indeed, being one of Hunter's most multi-layered lyrics, written in a sudden spurt of creativity during a trip to England that even the author can't explain. This too though is a hymn of faith that this world is all part of a bigger plan, that in the song's most quoted phrase 'there is a fountain that is not touched by the hands of man' (though whether planted by God alien or Deadhead time-travelling from the future is never explained). 'Brokedown Palace' and 'Attics Of My Life' both mourn a lost comrade that the narrator once had faith in. One reading of the former song is that a city-dweller turns their back on everything they know to re-join with nature, while the latter song is a nostalgic song about missed opportunities and a realisation that life was better with someone to share it with. Even the song's most famous moment 'Truckin' - originally intended as a song that would be updated with every tour and twist in the story - is a song about the band's relationship with their fans and their mutual faith that their shared journey was one worth taking, with every drug bust, bum gig and tiring tour worth it when added against the brilliance that was shared between the two over the years.

Many a fan has also speculated about the 'American' part of the title. The Dead never make any reference to their homeland again (bar a sparring 'US Blues' in 1974) and while they feature several 'outlaws' and 'cowboys' in their work there isn't the heavy sense of American History you get from, say, The Beach Boys or The Byrds. This album doesn't really have an Americana theme either (although 'Friend Of The Devil' features another Western setting and both 'Truckin' and 'Operator' make more sense with America settings of telephones, technology and outdoor concerts in the park) but it 'feels' American somehow, with all that could-have-been-recorded-in-alog-cabin monochrome about it and the similarity of many of the all-vocal arrangements to Appalachian Mountain folk songs. Perhaps that's why the band chose the cover, which starts a lifelong association with roses (often clenched in the teeth of skeletons). The rose pictured on the front cover is indeed an 'American Beauty' according to my resident botanist specialist (as for me the only plant I can name is the guy in Led Zeppelin) but regular artists Kelly and Mouse have been doubly clever here. The title, written in almost-illegible spidery writing, is just ambiguous enough to read ‘American reality’ if you squint at it hard enough - a clever double title reflecting on what could be as well as what is (either that, or my eyesight’s gone a bit wonky).

Pretty, picture-perfect songs of Americana then but still with the bite of old, this is in many ways the Dead album to rule above all others and the perfect introduction for non-fans scared away by 27 minute timings and Pigpen rapping about goodness knows what over the soundtrack of Armageddon. Funnily enough even the Deadheads who adored that sort of thing seem to have loved this album on the whole, perhaps rightly sensing that as there was no way the band could ever have topped 'Live/Dead' than at least they weren't trying. If only there were more albums like it – and the two records to come in 1971 and 1972 do include a highly respectable follow-up, albeit hidden amongst a double and triple record's worth of filler respectively. However, bored of the time needed to rehearse and develop these songs and never the most comfortable bunch of musicians when in the confined space of a cold studio, the band turned back to making live records instead. There’s a three year gap before the Dead’s next studio album and, surprise, surprise, that’s one of our 'core' reviews too. After all, what other Dead album contains as many songs as perfectly formed as this album? The lyrics to 'Box Of Rain' and 'Attics Of My  Life' are tremendous, being somehow realistic and life-affirming all in one go. 'Friend Of The Devil' is a cheery, cheeky song that's irresistible and in true Dead card game analogy plays it's cards so close to its chest we don't know whether the narrator really is the villainous rogue the people make him out to be or the tired boy whose gone too far to go back and can't run any further, his fiance and the town sheriff both after him for different reasons. 'Sugar Magnolia' is by far the best of Bob's goes at writing the ultimate rock song to have the crowd on their feet (even if here the song still shares some of its DNA with the other country-rockers). 'Truckin' is legendary for a reason, a postmodern self-referencing song that shouldn't work but does so wonderfully, getting by with a couple of classy couplets and sheer cheek. Both 'Attics' and 'Candyman' are right up there as the most exquisite Dead recordings of them all, poignant and moving without going OTT. Set against this the only ammunition the nay-sayers have is that Pigpen has written a better song for himself than 'Operator' down the years and misogynist chorus on the otherwise rocking 'Till The Morning Comes' is unfortunate, being so un-Dead like you wonder how it came about. Still, that's nothing - after all you couldn't have a perfect Dead album could you, or it wouldn't be the perfect Dead album because the perfect Dead album would show their imperfections and thus quid pro quo the only perfect Dead album can be an imperfect Dead album which of course means it isn't perfect. Or something like that - I got a bit lost. What I do know is that 'American Beauty' is that rare beast - an album that fans like, critics like and I like, a masterpiece in miniature that's rightly hailed as one of the greatest things they ever did and a record whose timeless radiance still shines as strongly all these years on.

The Songs:

Box Of Rain is a rare Phil Lesh outing, both musically and vocally, and it’s a fine outing to have, being one of the most moving songs about death in the American canon. A wistful, soul-searching tune written in the car one day while Phil was escaping from the album’s sessions to visit his father gradually dying in hospital, this song’s wistful sigh, down-casting lines and restless melody is moving enough on its own. Hunter’s words are the perfect fit, however: moving without being overly sentimental and forward looking as well as back, they encourage the listener that their grief won’t last forever and that life will carry on, just as it does for all the ‘other’ people the narrator enviously gazes at, going about their usual tasks because their life hasn’t just caved in by this terrible personal incident like the narrator feels it should have done. (The line ‘Maybe you’ll find direction around some corner where its been waiting to meet you’ after verses of the narrator aimlessly sleepwalking his way through life, stunned at the events going on in his life, is one of the best of the Dead’s whole career). Phil phrases his lines so that he sounds as shrugging off a big weight, even though the song is muted-jolly and bouncy, trying its best to recover and right itself throughout. The song ends with an added kick, however; reminding us of the shortness of life as the last line both (‘such a long long time to be gone, such a short time to be there’) hits the narrator with a new wave of grief and encourages him gently to move on with his life or he too will run out of time to have a family that care for him just as much as he cares for his missing relation now. One of the most moving songs in the Dead’s canon, this song was eerily revived towards the end of the Dead’s touring life after an absence of more than 20 years in the setlists (unusual for the Dead who revived anything and everything they could —even oddities like the Beatles’ fragment Why Don’t We Do It In The Road was performed in their shows for a time along with a good dozen other Beatles songs and thousands more oddities like this one over the years). Chosen as the second and final encore for the Dead’s last ever concert on July 9th 1995, a month to the day before Jerry’s own death, this was an eerily fitting song for the Dead to unknowingly bow out their thirty year career on, with their last notes to their fan-base being to ‘carry on’ without them despite the big hole their absence caused (and is still causing). Live performances: 157

Friend Of The Devil is one of several almost apologetic songs Garcia and Hunter wrote about hanging out with the ‘wrong’ crowd (classic anti-heroes, their song Dire Wolf on the previous album celebrates all of the wrongdoings most bands of the time were busy turning into anthems and then ending with the cowardly chorus ‘please don’t murder me’). The album’s country leanings are at their strongest on this song and its pretty tune is sweet enough to make you forget the troubles the narrator is hastily running away from. Lesh’s rumbling bass and the Garcia-Weir tricky guitar picking tries to give the narrator some urgency, but Garcia’s vocal is laidback in the extreme and seems content to spend his life running away from the law after succumbing to the temptation of the devil’s easy money in his youth. Despite fitting Garcia’s voice as snugly as a winter glove, the guitarist’s only songwriting contribution to this song was the lesser ‘sweet anne marie’ middle section; the rest of the song was written by Hunter with John Dawson of New Riders of the Purple sage and hijacked for the Dead when Garcia heard his friend’s demo tape and fell in love with it. Chances are you might too - its one of those infectious fun-loving songs with a performance that really gets to grips with the narrator’s laidback charm and the menace that lurks behind the piece. Live performances: 305

Sugar Magnolia is a similar Bob Weir magnum opus where heavy country and lightweight rock seem to meet head on and is one of both Weir and Hunter’s prettier songs (although the country lilt here soon gave the way to out-and-out rock on stage). A celebratory song about an imaginary fan-come-guardian angel the narrator spots bathing one hot summer, the title character seems too good to be true (she even pays the narrator’s speeding tickets, most memorably) and the song has enough humour to be pretty without being hackneyed. The key line of this song is ‘she’s my summer love for spring, fall and winter’, with the idea that even the harshness of life will somehow be dissipated by the presence of such a fun-loving supportive character by the narrator’s side, through thick or thin. The band’s delightful scat harmonies and the sudden melancholy key change in the last verse (‘Sometimes when the night is dying…’) are impressive too, throwing just the right spanner into the works at just the right time and show that the band had been listening to a lot of CSN records. The song’s coda ‘sunshine daydream’ became a whole new song in its own right in the 70s, when the band extended it a la Hey Jude into a rousing crowd singalong of optimism, a job for which this sweet song was well suited. Live performances: a ridiculous 589!

Operator is Pigpen’s showpiece and sadly not one of his best (Pigpen’s last batch of songs, especially Two Souls In Communion, would probably win that accolade but alas Pig died of liver failure before the Dead could make any proper recordings of them). However, the man born Ron McKernan’s bluesy wail and outlaw persona are always good to hear, even when stuck to the side of a decidedly simple song about the narrator’s increasingly desperate attempts to trace his sweetheart via an early version of directory enquiries. In truth, of course, the telephone operator would have hung up long before the end of the narrator’s spiel - and probably charged him extra for wasting her time in the process – and out of all the songs on the record this is probably the one fans have least ‘connected’ with over the years. However, stuck with only three minutes to make his mark, Pig’s vocal and especially his harmonic playing are impressive, adding a touch of earthy blues to the album despite this song’s pop trappings. Good on ya Pigpen, if only you’d lived a bit longer you’d be a much bigger hero to Dead fans than you are now and would undoubtedly have had a much stronger presence on this list. Live performances: 4

Garcia’s exquisite Candyman ends side one on top form. Shimmering, moody and with one of its composer’s loveliest sweeping melodies, Candyman is a haunting composition, eerily drifting its way through its multiple sections on a bed of ghostly harmonies. The melancholy of the song is added to by Garcia’s wistful pedal steel guitar playing - the sound of crying captured in an instrument - which plays one of the most heartbreaking solos you will ever hear. The ambiguous lyrics are some of Hunter’s cleverest too, about a woman’s awkward dependence on either an outside lover, liquor or drugs, depending on how you reads the deliberately ambiguous lyrics. Hunter’s un-named character in this song is a masterpiece of subtle writing, making the listener sympathise with her because her craving is not specifically for alcohol or drugs – its for the return of her ‘dealer’ who is a contact of the outside world in her lonely life. She may also be passing the illicit substances to her friends rather than taking them herself, seeing this as a way to get popular even though the friendships it makes are hollow and sporadic at best – ‘pretty lady ain’t got no friends till the candyman comes around again’ indeed. Like the song’s yearning tune, this ominous song craves to be a happier tale and Garcia’s grandfatherly vocal does its best to put us at ease, but its clear that despite the character’s elation when the candyman calls, it will only end in tears somewhere along the line. The band almost sleepwalk their way through this performance and Garcia sounds prematurely old, pre-cursing the paper thin vocals he will have for real on the band’s 80s recordings, a state of affairs entirely in keeping with this tale of reluctant addiction. Whether Garcia identified with the song or not (despite what you may read, any addictions he did have were never out of control until the late 1970s at the earliest) the song still seems to have brought out the best in him. Weary and sombre, yet audibly forcing himself to try to be happy, his brief heartbroken ‘oh’ coming out of the solo and into a verse about scrounging money for the candyman’s next visit says far more to the listener than what we get from just reading the lyric sheet. The band’s harmonies then add a final touch by enveloping the song in a fog of downbeat sympathy. All in all, Candyman is a lovely track and one of the best the Dead ever recorded. Live performances: 270

Ripple is more of the same but rather more upbeat this time, a wordy but beautifully expressed Garcia-Hunter song about moving forward against obstacles and with a tune that sounds like an old folk tale being told round a steaming campfire. Hunter’s lyrics are especially fine, touching on the fact that modern mankind is just as unsure about their purpose in life as their ancestors were. The song also taps into religious beliefs, drawing on the idea that the Earth has been handed on by some unseen force whose ‘ripples’ are still felt, even though this presence left long ago. This ‘presence’ can still be reached by spiritual beauty (via a ‘fountain that was not made by the hands of men’) that fills up the ‘life-force’ of the men left behind and guides them in the right direction - although ultimately the narrator reveals he is just as unsure about the whole thing as everybody else is (after telling us that each of us must follow their own journey in life he adds ‘If I knew the way I would take you home’). An impressive lyric then, and Garcia’s singalong tune is impressive too. However, the recording of this song is unfortunately one of American Beauty’s few lapses in taste: the band’s harmonies aren’t as tight as on other parts of the record and the choir that sings along rather flatly and wordlessly to the last verse sounds anything but inspired, whether by the band or mankind’s ambivalent creator. Live performances: 41

Brokedown Palace repeats the trick again, with a typical singalong Garcia melody matching the philosophical lyrics comfortably, although the funeral tempo makes it a bit more of a struggle to sit through than the other tracks that surround it. A song of goodbyes, with the narrator recovering from a social fall and finding solace in nature, the song makes nice use of the band’s growing harmony technique, although its emotion and melancholy are rather overdone and theatrical compared to the rest of the album. Desperate to create something lasting now that his old relationship has fallen through, the narrator gives us mixed messages by choosing weeping willows to plant and help flower, suggesting along with the mournful tune that he’s not quite got over his problems yet. Then again, is the narrator in fact committing suicide here – ‘river going to take me, sing sweet and sleepy’ suggests that the narrator has in actual fact had enough of everything and is in fact clocking off, not to the love of his life that has died but to us, those left stuck in the ‘real world’. The Dead don’t quite do this sweet song justice in their arrangement this time around and—given what this song might be about— the closing verse of doo-doo-doos make for a particularly unsatisfactory end. Live performances: 218

Till The Morning Comes is another of side two’s backward steps, without the depth of the other songs on the album. The tune is poppy and an acoustic Dead-interpreted version of Merseybeat if you can imagine such a thing, while Hunter’s lyrics are uncharacteristically sexist in the narrator’s insistence that ‘you’re my woman now’. The song just sounds so juvenile within the context of an album about the deeper mysteries of mankind and the music reflects that too, turning back not just to mid-60s pop but to the Dead's earlier electric feel (this and 'Truckin' are the only songs where Garcia picks up a guitar that isn't a pedal steel, something that would have been unthinkable even a year ago!) Still, the harmonies are impressive and the tune itself is likeable, moving between the very different verse and chorus structures with cohesion and ease, and even the verses about the narrator losing his tracks in the snow and being unable to retrace his steps have much to recommend. Live performances: 5

Even so, best to skip on to Attics of My Life, with the sound now totally dominated by the strained but noble harmonies of Garcia, Lesh and Weir on a courageous sparse arrangement that would test even the most experienced and professional of singers. The song also features Garcia and Hunter back to their compositional best. Garcia’s tune is simply gorgeous, even played at a half-speed funeral-tempo here to place emphasise on Hunter’s poetic lyrics. These are typically obtuse yet still accessible enough to be moving, with their very real devotion to a person who verse by verse sings when the narrator cannot hear, plays strings when there is no instrument to play, flies when he has no wings and dreams when the narrator’s imagination is empty. Like Sugar Magnolia, this is the soul-mate to end all others, the one who can ‘fill in’ the gaps that the narrator just can’t quite reach and making up for his faults by giving him the inspiration to overcome them. Almost hymnal in its use of chords, this gorgeous song of devotion is a tribute to someone who helped the narrator back from the edge at his lowest point, helping him to believe in life by believing in him first, helping him clear the ‘attics’ of his mind where his subconscious fears and doubts have been working overtime. Beautiful and simple, this is the acoustic Dead at their best and never have the Dead sounded, if you excuse the pun, more alive than here. Live performances: 51

Things close out on rocking form with the autobiographical Truckin’, a hilarious philosophically shoulder-shrugging song still perfectly in keeping with this album of universal ideas and gentle philosophy. Hunter only really knew Garcia well at this point in the band’s history and had been with the Dead a scant two years and three albums and yet his lyrics are perfectly placed to incorporate both the Dead’s outsider status and their down-to-earthness, always ploughing their own merry road despite authority figures, record labels and self-inflicted obstacles getting in their way. The tune, written by Garcia, Lesh and Weir between them (Weir takes the lead vocal for the second time on this album) is gentle grooving rock, perfectly designed for the dual purposes of being catchy and simple enough for airplay and exotic and spacious enough to leave gaps for long improvisations in concert. Another popular choice with fans, not least the tip of the hat to the dysfunctional band’s equally dysfunctional fans, this is also a great song about the love that flows between the two sides, as both sides get into trouble accidentally for their personal idiosyncrasies yet again. Bravely pointing out the lows of the journey as well as the highs, this is the band re-grouping and deciding that, despite being unable to wait until going home and ending the ride, the band members aren’t built for any purpose other than the one they have and while resting can’t wait to go trucking off again. Originally 'Truckin' was intended as an open ended song that the band would keep adding to over time, sticking in references to new incidents and  enabling the band to 'keep in touch' with their fans while partly controlling their own mythology from the comfort of the stage. Alas, though, that wasn't to be and 'Truckin' was received from the first as the closest to a 'perfect' song the Dead came up with - which meant everyone was reluctant to change it. That's a shame; it would have been fascinating to hear how a maturer Garcia and Hunter reflected on their youthful follies some twenty years on and could have become the best running joke on the business, updated for each new President/celebrity/lifestyle choice that was below par. Still, perhaps it was best to let things lie as those pithy four verses are inherently quotable and sum up nicely the Dead philosophy. ‘Sometimes we represent truth, sometimes we get it wrong’, the band say, ‘its up to you to decide whether you ought to follow us—’cause we haven’t got a clue whether what we’re doing is important or not’. Live performances: an extraordinary 521


Come on guys, how we can we not follow you after hearing this extraordinary album? Both pioneering and brave enough to win over the band’s old fans and beautiful enough to win the Dead a whole lot of new ones, American Beauty is a classic of its kind. Who would have thought back in the mid-60s that the Dead would create such a layered, polished, crafted and harmony laden masterpiece? The best proof available of how talented as musicians and writers the bands had to be to head off into the unknown stratosphere night after night in concert, this record has been single-handedly silencing the band’s critics and nay-sayers ever since its release.  Magic with lashings of pedal steel, this is the kind of Dead album everybody ought to own.


Other Dead related articles from this site you might be interested in reading:


‘Live/Dead’ (1969) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/05/grateful-dead-livedead-1969.html

'Workingman's Dead' (1970) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2012/03/news-views-and-music-issue-138-grateful.html

'American Beauty' (1970) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2008/07/review-40-grateful-dead-american-beauty.html
'Blues For Allah' (1975) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/03/grateful-dead-blues-for-allah-1975.html

'Terrapin Station' (1977) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2010/08/news-views-and-music-issue-72-grateful.html
'Shakedown Street' (1978) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2016/04/grateful-dead-shakedown-street-1978.html
'Go To Heaven' (1980) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2014/09/grateful-dead-go-to-heaven-1980-album.html
'In The Dark' (1987) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com/2013/12/grateful-dead-in-dark-album-review.html

'Built To Last' (1989) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2008/10/news-views-and-music-issue-7-grateful.html
Surviving TV Clips 1966-1994 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-surviving-tv-clips-1967.html
The Best Unreleased Recordings 1966-1993 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-best-unreleased.html
The Last Unfinished Album 1990-1995 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-last-unfinished-album.html
Live/Solo/Compilations Part One 1966-1976 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-official.html
Live/Solo/Compilations Part Two 1978-2011 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/06/grateful-dead-official_29.html
A Guide To The CD Bonus Tracks http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/07/grateful-dead-guide-to-cd-bonus-tracks.html
Dick's Picks/Dave's Picks http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/07/grateful-dead-dicks-picksdaves-picks.html
Road Trips/Download Series/Miscellaneous Archive Releases
http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/07/grateful-dead-road-tripsdownload.html

Essay: Why The ‘Dead’ Made Fans Feel So ‘Alive’ https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2018/01/grateful-dead-essay-why-dead-makes-fans.html
Five Landmark Concerts and Three Key Cover Versions https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2018/03/grateful-dead-five-landmark-concerts.html