Monday, 21 August 2017

10cc and Godley-Creme: Surviving TV Clips and Music Videos 1970-1995 and Best Unreleased Recordings


You can now buy 'Memories - The Alan's Album Archives Guide To The Music Of 10cc' in e-book form by clicking here!


















At last, after several book entries that feature AAA stars who shyly stand on stage, hide behind their amplifiers or are working for such primitive early television stations that they get their one and only prop caught in their chair midway through the performance (I'm looking at you Cat Stevens!), we get a band who know what they're doing when it comes to the art of visuals. The publicity for 10cc's third album 'The Original Soundtrack' claimed that the band were making 'movies for the blind' and that sums up their approach to their layered, character-driven music rather well - each 10cc song seems as if it lives in its own world, at least on the early records. Making films to accompany those soundtracks was the next natural step, even if 10cc somehow managed to remain strangely obscure and 'Pink Floydy' into the 1970s shyly hiding behind their image and (by and large) ignoring interviews and letting their music speak for them. The band were early unsung pioneers of the music video as early as 1977, even before Godley-Creme broke away and became experts at the things (their work as directors for other people include some of the biggest hits of the 1980s such as Duran Duran's 'Girls On Film', Frankie Goes To Hollywood's 'Relax' and 'Two Tribes' and two songs for two ex-Beatles, Paul McCartney's 'C'mon People' and George Harrison's 'We Was Fab'). The duo quickly became famous for their quirky, unusual and - for the times - groundbreaking ideas that make them standout in the MTV video age, whether it be robot mannequins repeating stock phrases in New York, crying faces morphing into one another or whatever the hell is going on in 'Mondo Video' (more than thirty years on and I still haven't got a clue!) Given that Godley-Creme were, for a decade or so, synonymous with videos we've decided to give them their own special 'spin-off' section at the end of this article. However it should be remembered that 10cc were pretty revolutionary at times too with their work which we feature in full first, with most of their appearances in this list coming after the split.

Usually these articles tend to be mimed-performance or interview heavy, but perfectionists in visuals as well as sound and always fiercely independent, 10cc tended to prefer making videos to send off round the world instead. They got more control that way and - as they became more confident - made up videos as elaborate as the songs they accompanied. At least until after Eric Stewart's car crash in 1979 slowed sales and forced the band out into the public arena a little bit more, with multiple video/TV concerts towards the end of their first career as 10cc tried to embrace their fading public again. Sadly their end in 1983 just as MTV was growing meant they never got the respect they deserved for being ahead of the trend, which Godley-Creme experienced. The reunion years of 1992 and 1995 should have seen the world catch up with 10cc's way of doing things, but after so much agony making their two records together Eric and Graham seem to have done as little as possible rather than spend any time together. Sadly the music world still doesn't think of 10cc as pioneers of the video age, even though they were there before Queen, Genesis and a million other bands better associated with the medium. It didn't help that for years your only way of getting hold of the promos was the long-deleted hour-long video 'Changing Faces' in 1987 (half of which features Godley-Creme anyway - it was repackaged as 'Greatest Hits and More' in 2006 to go alongside a compilation, with no extra material), though thankfully the DVD disc in the 'Tenology' box set of 2012 has included a lot more footage and remains by far the best place to look for your 10cc video collection.

We'll tell you where things are available officially where we can - till then I'm afraid our 10cc Youtube playlist will have to make do! Simply visit https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL5DEEF4A715870BE2 or have a look in Youtube's search engine for 'Alan's Album Archives Playlist #28: 10cc' and you should find them all - well, all the ones currently available on Youtube anyway (many of the officially available ones have been taken down since the box set came out!) Not quite everything is there - and Yotube playlists have a habit of missing bits and pieces after a while, though we'll try and keep the page as up to date as we can - but that should fill in a few of the original soundtracks for you that you've only ever heard as songs till now anyway. Bear in mind too that few people ever took dates of transmission down so this list is at best a work in progress, where the order is vague at best and there might be something missing (10cc seemed to like appearing on obscure European television channels near the end, so there may well be a late night show in Prague I haven't seen yet or something - feel free to send any omissions in!) The good news, though, is that as a 1970s vintage AAA band who specialised in shooting their own videos, practically everything has survived the years intact so there are none of the gaps where clips should be that other AAA artists have suffered. There has even been a last minute recent discovery of a Top Of The Pops performance from 1973 that's snuck into this list at the last minute (well, relatively - we're an establishment that caters in music from half a century ago, a couple of years ago is recent to us!)

So, join us now for our first 10cc clip, 'somewhere in Hollywood' (or Stockport anyway, close enough) back at a time when 10cc still had 'Hotlegs'.

1.    Neanderthal Man (Music Video 1970 as 'Hotlegs')
Recorded simply, Hotlegs' 'drum-testing' session took off so quickly that they couldn't have provided an elaborate video if they'd tried. So they didn't: instead of the sort of thing the band would probably do years later (a cartoon about a caveman or a mannekin neanderthal coming to life) they simply point a camera at each other in close-up and sing along. You wonder how it must have seemed for the public in the pre-10cc era, going 'gee I know them from somewhere - especially that blonde guitarist in the sunglasses. Didn't he used to be in The Mindbenders?!? Why is he singing about neanderthals making love?!' Lol makes for a good caveman and Kevin certainly has the hair for it (this is the longest it will be till 1988!) but Eric seems greatly bemused by the whole thing! No Graham of course - he wasn't on this track, though he does guest on the album.

2.    Disco ('Desperate Dan' UK TV 1970 as 'Hotlegs')
A weird choice - a novelty song that wasn't released a single and certainly wasn't disco in anyway shape or form, mimed by a band who look deeply uncomfortable (especially Eric once again!) Nobody in the audience seems to notice that the band aren't playing half the instruments heard on the original tapes (including the piano, the loudest thing here!)

3.    Donna (Music Video 1972)
A straightforward mimed video that looks suspiciously like a TOTP appearance, complete with a similarly bored looking audience. Lol has great fun going OTT and getting his cues 'wrong' (mind you, Kevin is even worse!) Lol then gets the giggles answering the 'phone'. Sadly this promo doesn't make 10cc 'sit down' or 'stand up' and they're rather static here, but it's good to see them having fun in comparison to their more serious promos! Available on the 'Tenology' box set.

4.    Top Pop #1 ('Donna' Holland TV June 1972)
Meanwhile, over in Holland 10cc debut on a show they played a lot - it's the Dutch equivalent of 'Top Of The Pops' that ran for almost as long (eighteen years from 1970-1988) but a bit more 'fun'! It even 'invented' punk rock thanks to Iggy Pop appearing there in 1977 and being in such a foul mood he destroyed the set live on air! Even TOTP, for instance, would never have had the band stuck at the back of the stage as the 'backing band' for a busty dancer who completely upstages them! Also look out for the backdrop, which is hard to see but is a large cut out of the name '10cc' in different shapes and sizes (this might be a comment on how much smaller than others Lol looks on this clip! Later he'll stand on things to look taller).  Lol and Kevin are still awful at miming on cue...

5.    Top Of The Pops #1 ('Rubber Bullets' UK TV 1973)
Only recently returned to the archives in early 2015, this is 10cc's debut for the 'real' Top Of The Pops'. Even taking into account the quality isn't top notch it looks as if the band were already going for an 'arty' look with weird lighting and crashing zooms from the cameras - the traditional thing TOTP cameraman do with something that looks a bit 'different', be it punk or novelty hits! The band are also obscured by the spotlights, but at least their miming has improved - at least until the 'Sgt Baker made a beeline to the jail' line which Lol messes up spectacularly!

6.    Top Pop #2 ('The Worst Band In The World' Holland TV 1973)
This single never did that well in the charts but the band give their all during this Dutch performance. You can tell that the band are much more comfortable with two big hits under their belt though and this postmodernist classic is the most 10cc single yet. It's easy to get distracted by the backing though, which features a close-up of the Statue of Liberty for no apparent reason in a dazzling array of colours! At last after eight years of watching his songs become hits for other people Graham Gouldman gets to look the camera squarely in the eye and sing on this track ('Never seen the van - leave it to the roadies, never seen the roadies - leave 'em in the van!') Watch out for an early version of Eric's 'bow-legged dance' at the end.

7.    Top Of The Pops #2 ('Rubber Bullets' Christmas Special UK 1973)
The year 1973 had been a huge one for the sale of singles and pop music was now so mainstream TOTP even had a special on Christmas Day! All the biggest bands of the year were invited back to play their biggest hits and thus came perhaps the most commonly sighted 10cc clip of them all. The band are in a 'party' mood, playing this double-edged song for laughs instead of the grim humour they sometimes employed in concert. Included on the 'Tenology' box set.

8.    See You On Sunday ('Fresh Air For My Mama' 'The Wall Street Shuffle' UK TV April 1974)
A slightly heavy-handed guest appearance on a shirt-lived music show, although at least it gave 10cc the chance to play more than just their current hit single, with a moody version of 'Fresh Air For My Mama' from the debut LP outstripping a slightly cautious 'Wall Street Shuffle'. Included on the 'Tenology' box set.

9.    BBC In Concert ('SSSSSilly Love' 'The Wall Street Shuffle' 'Baron Samedi' 'Old Wild Men' 'Oh Effendi!' 'Fresh Air For My Mama' 'Rubber Bullets' UK TV August 1974)
A thrilling entry in the regular AAA appearances on the BBC's half-hour  'In Concert' shows of the early 1970s, with 10cc at the peak of their live act in this era and with everyone except poor Graham getting their turn on the spotlight. The band have by now given up trying to re-create their polished records and have turned into a surprisingly aggressive live act, drivene by Graham's slightly-before-the-beat bass and Kevin's slightly behind-the-beat-drums. Several songs sound entirely different to the way they do on album - hungrier, angrier and a lot more from the heart than from the head. Take 'SSSSSilly Love', a slightly arch single about trying to avoid saying cliches in love that not many fans enjoy but which heard here knocks the socks off anything a heavier rock band of the time could do, especially the lengthy riffing finale and Eric's blistering solo (which, sadly, we never really get a decent close-up of!) 'The Wall Street Shuffle' is a little wonky and more than a little fast, with Eric miked too loud, but Graham's busy bass and Lol's guitar stings more than makes up for it. This version is more of a howl of pain too than the intellectual tutting of the record. 'Old Wild Men' is the highlight, with the unusual song stripped of all the production effects and sounded mouch more raw and emotive, with Kevin singing lower and Lol giving an early airing to his guitar's 'gizmo' stringbending device. The closing swirl of harmonies is divine, proving that 10cc can do beauty as well as power. A closing 'Rubber Bullets' is the most 'natural' of the many TV clips of this song around, played for sarcasm and outrage as much as laughs and ending with an angry ongoing rocking finale hat goes on for hours which is much darker and more angular than the one on the 'album' mix (the single mix cuts this bit entirely). 'Baron Samedi' is a mess though, all percussion and not much happening, while a tougher, brittler 'Fresh Air For My Mama' isn't a patch on the one played on 'See You On Sunday'. Still you can't have everything - 10cc are on it for most of this set and you can see their 'democracy' at work particularly well with everyone pulling together - you wouldn't think the big split was less than a couple of years away. All in all an excellent archive clip and one of the best of the original 10cc that exists.  Interestingly Lol is centre-stage now, where Eric used to stand on the earlier performances, while the band have been joined by second drummer Paul Burgess for the first time, so that Kevin can think about singing as well as playing sometimes. A highly under-rated player, he'll be with the band up until 1980. You can see the whole half hour of this show on the 'Tenology' box set, as well as frequent repeats on BBC4 if you live in Britain!

10. Don Kirshner's Rock Concert ('The Dean and I' 'Rubber Bullets' US TV 1974)
You might remember Don Kirshner as the 'baddy' from our Monkees book, releasing singles without consulting the group and refusing to let them have any say over their own recordings. Nearly a decade later and Kirshner has had mixed success; The Archies were his 'other' big band (because cartoons can't answer back!) but most of his records had fallen off the charts by 1974. Instead he fancied himself as a TV impresario (if Ed Sullivan could do it while getting everyone's names wrong and high on painkillers, why not him?) and put together a similar musical variety show that ran between 1973 and 1981 before new wave and punk finally drove him off the air. 10cc were one of his earliest guests and appeared in a line miming to two of their earliest songs, now a couple of years old, under some weird strobe lighting effects. The band don't exactly break a sweat on either song but are very in tune with each other by now, with their miming spot-on for every word. perhaps the biggest American audience 10cc ever played to.

11. Top Of The Pops #3 (Life Is A Minestrone UK April 1975)
In many ways 'Minestrone' is a spoof of the typical glam-rock-single-with-stupid-metaphors that were so ripe in the mid-1970s. So it makes sense that 10cc perform the song in front of a typically tacky glam background, with their name in glittering grey lights and yet more round white lights on a loop round the group. Did it get 10cc more fanmail than the Pope? Probably not, with Lol keeping his eyes tight shut for most of his last lead vocal single for the band.

12. 'I'm Not In Love (Music Video 1975)
Some pulsing and very 1970s graphics give way to a timeless song, delivered here 'straight' by the band as if every word they're saying is the gospel truth. Eric finds it hard to hide the dreamy look in his eyes though. Everyone assumes the 'circle of faces' around Eric singing the high synthesised 'aaaahs' is ripped off Queen's 'Bohemian Rhapsody' but no: the 10cc promo was first aired in May 1975; Queen's in October the same year. That band borrowed so many ideas off 10cc! Kevin looks quite scary when he suddenly grows in size... Also the fact all men are standing around playing synthesisers looks very early 1980s and is a style copied by many bands from The Human League to Kraftwerk. Another 'Tenology' refugee, though oddly the 'Changing Faces' compilation replaces it with a live version from the 1978 touring band (though shot in the studio) and ends it with a 'yeah yeah yeah yeah ye-e-e-ah'.

13. Art For Art's Sake (Music Video 1976)
Moody lighting for a moody song, with sudden dramatic flourishes for the chorus. Eric is taking more and more of the centre stage now, though Graham steals the show for his deep bass vocal parts. Included on the 'Tenology' box set.

14. I'm Mandy, Fly Me (Music Video 1976)
A relative disappointment, 10cc could have done so much with the video for this song. After all, how much more visual can you get than a hallucinating airplane passenger saved by the hallucination of the air hostess on the poster above his seat? Alas the band just sit around playing as normal behind a revolving version of their logo, bookending the song with parts where they stand in a line and look oddly menacing. Included on both the 'Tenology' and 'Changing Faces' sets.

15. Don't Hang Up (Music Video 1976)
A rather poignant goodbye, with the last song on the last Godley-Creme era 10cc record featuring the drummer struggling to cope with a breakup and pleading with the others not to hang up the phone. It may just be really good acting to fit the song, but there's a real sense of poignancy and melancholia about this performance. It seems an odd song to make a video for this of all songs too, given that it was never released as a single and by the time they filmed it everybody knew this line-up of 10cc was 'over'. Included in the 'Tenology' box set.

16. Live At Knebworth ('Rubber Bullets' Concert 1976)
Presumably 10cc performed more than just one song when they appeared as second-in-the-line-up to The Rolling Stones in Knebworth's third annual music festival. The band's performance is their scrappiest yet and they can feel it too, Lol getting the most 'frontman' he ever got and screaming to the '200,000 people' in the crowd and giggling as he mimics the 'siren' sound better than the siren sound effect the band have on stage. The band are fragmenting like crazy and are holding on for grim death through this neverending version of one of their bigger songs that last for a full thirteen minutes (it has to be split into two parts if you're watching it on Youtube, posted back in the days when videos could only last ten minutes). The band have lost touch with the song long before the end and seem to be playing just for the hell of it. A sad way for the original 10cc to end, especially as none of the band will ever play in front of crowds this big again and Lol and Kevin certainly won't, even though Creme has got the act of fronting a band down fine by this point!

17. Top Of The Pops #4 ('The Things We Do For Love' UK TV January 1977)
By now 10cc are down to three, with Paul Burgess at last a full-time member. However the band try to carry on as if nothing has happened, with lots of 'trick-shots' that allow Eric to seem like he's playing both piano and guitar. It's perhaps the most straightforward video in this list but that's no bad thing - adding a gimmick to a song this catchy-yet-deep would have been a waste. Eric's hair is at the longest in this video too for those hairdressers amongst you keeping score! Included on the 'Changing Faces' disc but oddly not the 'Tenology' set. Some rights issue probably, given that the BBC own this one.

18. Good Morning Judge (Music Video 1977)
This promo is a lot more fun and the first evidence of 10cc thinking outside the book in their visuals, oddly just after Godley and Creme - future famed directors - have left. Eric and Graham appear multiple times over as an assortment of very different looking jurors (Eric looks very good with a full beard!) Graham plays the stern looking judge whilst Eric gets all the fun things to do, like robbing a car and running off with a 'shiny thing' (actually a girl!) Both judge and suspect get to play guitar in the courtroom which is surely contempt of court, while Eric and Graham end up in prison by the end (check out Gouldman's scar!) This video may well have been inspired by George Harrison's very similar 'This Song' from the previous year, a satirical take on his being sued for plagiarism that uses several of the same gags. Included on 'Tenology' and 'Changing Faces' and rightly so.

19. People In Love (Music Video 1977)
The song that helped split 10cc up (Godey-Creme hated it!) this slightly drippy third single from 'Deceptive Bends' gets a suitably drippy video. Eric sits alone at a white piano (this video taking its cue from a different ex-Beatle!) while getting doey-eyed with a silly romantic look on his face. Poor Graham barely features, which is a shame because his wild perm is the most convincing thing about this clip! Included on 'Tenology' , where it's the one everyone skips in between 'Judge' and 'Dreadlock Holiday'.


20. Live At The Hammersmith Odeon ('Good Morning Judge' 'I'm Not In Love' 'Modern Man Blues' 'Second Sitting For The Last Supper' 'Marriage Bureau Rendezvous' 'The Things We Do For Love' 'People In Love' 'The Wall Street Shuffle' 'Feel The Benefit' Concert June 1977 Released 1980)
A preview of what the new-look six-piece 10cc will sound like on the following year's 'Live and Let Live' concert album (recorded a month later), this show in London was filmed for The King Biscuit Flower Hour radio show - a soundtrack of the band performing for it in 1974 was released in the 21st century too. This show was released as a video in 1980 and is kind of a warm-up for the world tour to come and as such is slightly sloppy, exciting and energetic but not exactly tight. It's good fun though, especially the newer songs from 'Deceptive Bends' which sound a lot better here than they will on the official set oddly, tighter and rawer and a lot less tongue-in-cheek, Graham's strong take on 'Marriage Bureau Rendezvous' especially. An epic twelve minute take on 'Feel The Benefit' ever so nearly works too, holding the attention for longer than the 'Live and Let Live' one and with better gear-changes between the three main sections. The between-song patter is rather good too, with Eric embracing his new role as 'host' with digs at the director for the 'Good Morning Judge' promo sitting in the audience and throwing in jokes about the band. You do miss Lol and Kevin a lot though and all their songs are missing from the set-list so no 'Donna' 'Rubber Bullets' or 'Life Is A Minestrone', which is a great shame. Sadly this show has yet to appear on DVD which is a great shame as, while it's not as interesting as the 1974 'In Concert' set, it beats the 1992 'Alive' and 2006 'Clever Clogs' versions of the band hands down!

21. Dreadlock Holiday (Music Video 1978)
I don't love this video, but I like it-ah! Remembering their inspiration for the song (similar misadventures on separate holidays in the West Indies), Eric and Graham return there to shoot the video in the 'real' location. Sadly neither 10ccer 'acts' and instead they hire an outsider who swaggers around like the fish out of water he is (especially when he's pushed in the pool, fully clothed). The trio of Eric, Graham and Rick Fenn (in the middle) have got the 'swaying knees jig' down to a tee though when we cut back to the band in the choruses. Before you ask, no I've no idea why Graham pulls a 'shocked' face and shields his eyes from a 'light' at the very end either - the light of truth about the people out to con him perhaps? Inevitably included on both 'Tenology' and 'Changing Faces'.

22. Top Of The Pops #5 ('Dreadlock Holiday' UK TV 1978)
Another much-seen and oft-repeated clip that marks the band's last appearance on Top Of The Pops. Eric has a perm to match Graham's this time, whilst Eric 'gees' the band up (especially the wide-mouth laugh to the two drummers Paul and Stuart Tosh at the 1:30 mark) while Graham tries to stay serious. Sadly 10cc don't use the bow-legged dance this time around!

23. Top Pop #4 ('I'm Not In Love' Holland TV 1978)
I admit it, I haven't got a clue where this video goes but the 1978 line-up of the band perform it so that's why it's here. The second 10cc are effectively miming to the record made by the first and it's really odd to see the deep-voiced Rick open his mouth and have the Godley-falsetto come out of it, ditto the higher pitched Stuart Tosh who by now has the biggest perm of them all! Eric wears a bomber jacket for this one and looks to all intents and purposes like an RAF pilot. Made for Dutch television, who couldn't secure the rights to the original promo film.

24. HTV ('It Doesn't Matter At All' 1980)
Meanwhile, over in Wales (the 'H' stands for 'Harlech') 10cc are back after a break and playing live for the first time in a TV studio! They sound rather good too, especially Duncan Mackay's keyboards which are much louder than on the record and the note-perfect backing harmonies (which are presumably pre-recorded, given that Eric effectively sings twice!) The performance has a real swing about it and this sweet overlooked ballad actually comes across better than it does on the 'Look Hear' album.

25. One-Two-Five (Japanese TV/Music Video 1980)
The band mime to a new recording of this one, with Eric looking the rockstar part in his sunglasses. This is 10cc's coolest period in terms of 'look' (or at least the band clearly feel 'Hot To Trot') even though the song isn't one of their best (it gets badly cut in half too with a rotten edit down the middle!) Included on the 'Tenology' box set, rather surprisingly given how much is missing from the later years on there.

26. Don't Ask (Music Video 1981)
...Such as this rare video in which the band stand around a load of grey backgrounds looking uncomfortable. The star of this show is Rick Fenn whose grown a full beard now rather than his normal moustache and who really puts his all into his mimed guitar solo (which sounds suspiciously like one of Eric's to me). These are the last appearances of the six-piece 10cc, but then again the album these tracks come from, 'Ten Out Of Ten', were mainly made by Eric and Graham, with a bit of Rick and Paul, anyway.

27. Don't Turn Me Away (Music Video 1981)
Presumably taped the same day (the band are in the same clothes and mime on the same sets!) Eric has switched to piano and is at his cute/shy/the-cameras-on-me-and-I-secretly-love-it best, while a sax player - presumably Lenni Crookes who played on the recording - hangs around looking bored. A bit of trick photography captured the band in freeze frame - sadly the expressions they pull at this point aren't the best!

28. Top Pop #5 ('Don't Turn Me Away' Holland TV 1981)
We're back in Holland for the last time - not that you'd know that from the set, which is firmly based in Egypt! Presumably Eric is an archaeologist turned away by his mummy ancestors - or maybe it was left over from The Bangles doing 'Walk Like An Egyptian', who knows?! We're back to the mimed appearances sadly and with a different saxophone player - perhaps a Dutch local given the costs of flying someone halfway round the world for a fifteen second mimed solo.

29. Multi-Coloured Swap Shop (UK TV 1981)
'No band ever sees themselves on stage so consequently they never get a clear picture of how they appear'. A most fascinating clip on prime-time children's TV that seems to be the only footage of the 1980-1981 tour (the last as a six-piece) that we've got. The Swap Shop team filmed the 10cc show in Birmingham, with interviews conducted the next night in Brighton. We start with scrappy footage of 'Rubber Bullets', recently added back to the set, and meet the roadies and technicians including Charlie the chief rigger (who looks like a topless David Gilmour) and Patrick the lighting engineer (who sounds a bit cheesed off with the stupid questions to be honest). It sounds like hard work: 'Altogether there are 250 boxes to be shifted and every one's a dead weight!' It's all very fascinating though, even if the crew are a little grumpy and patronising, especially in comparison in how much work went into shows years before and after for comparison and trust 10cc to give so much air-time to their support staff instead of stealing the limelight themselves. For those only interested in the band, though, they finally arrive some 12 minutes in and we get to eavesdrop as they catch their lift and head to the show. A great clip of the finale to 'I'm Not In Love' then follows, although sadly it rather undercuts most of what we've heard about the hard work setting up the lights by being shot in semi-blackness! Eric hung around the studio to see the film being played in and offers a rare interview to host Noel Edmonds. Shy and edgy, he's not the best interviewee but he offers some fascinating titbits and the old 10cc engineering perfectionism shows as he admits to '3 or 4 hours' of sound-check every night. Noel asks about becoming a '10cc of the future' and gets an interesting comment about the early days of The Mindbenders, as Eric built up Strawberry Studios two-track machines by four-track machines! One of the quirks of 'Swapshop' was that young fans get to call in and their questions are nearly always more interesting than the presenters. Eric gets asked his favourite and least favourite track and nominated 'I'm Not In Love' for the former and 'Dean and I' for the latter ('I always thought that was like something from South pacific and Lol and Kev got very angry with me!') Another caller asks about the split in 1976 and Eric admits 'it was a good thing for all of us' through gritted teeth and defensively claims that their first songs afterwards were 'more successful'. Interestingly he claims it was a 'business split' when Noel asks how personal it was but says that he'd be quite happy to get back together again 'one day' (it will happen, briefly, in 1992!) Eric then gets the inevitable question about where the band got its name and - given that he can't talk about ejaculations on children's telly - copes very well, cutting that bit of the story out and saying that Jonathan King got it in a dream. However he still comes unstuck when Noel asks what King is up to now - given that he was in prison on child pornography charges a laughing Eric tells him 'we see him in court occasionally these days!' Next question: how is touring financially viable for a six-piece and multiple crew? Short answer: it isn't, Eric admitting the band lose money but perform because they like it. The 'swap' (ie the prize given away to whoever answers a question right) is disappointing though: an unused jacket from the 10cc Japanese tour! The question's a hard one too - who was the architect who designed The Brighton Pavilion near where the clip was filmed; good luck answering that one! (It's John Nash if you were wondering - thanks Google, where's my jacket?!) Most episodes of 'Swap Shop' were wiped, so kudos to Ian Norman who worked on the show and kept a copy, uploading it to youtube so other fans could share it! The full half hour would make a fantastic extra on a 10cc DVD one day; it's a fascinating glimpse into 10cc as band and touring behemoth and well worth watching by all fans.

30. We've Heard It All Before! (Music Video 1982)
The single the band recorded with Andrew Gold, years before he joined Graham in 'Wax', this little seen video is the wackiest 10cc video of them all. Graham sings lead 'normally', Eric sings the middle eight dressed up in a Tuxedo and looking like an inter-war crooner! We may have heard something like this before, but never seen it!

31. Pebble Mill ('Run Away' UK TV 1982)
The 1980s incarnation of 'The One Show' (random guests, very random subjects and extremely random presenters) doesn't really suit the quirkiness of 10cc and one of their quieter, gentler songs gets a bit lost in between items on household goods. It's interesting to note how 'mainstream' these TV appearances are becoming though now that 10cc's sales have started falling but alas even the exposure and some of their finest work isn't enough to stem the tide.

32. Live At Wembley ('Art For Art's Sake' 'Lying Here With You' 'The Power Of Love' 'I'm Mandy Fly Me' 'The Things We Do For Love' 'The Wall Street Shuffle' 'Dreadlock Holiday' 'I'm Not In Love' 'Feel The Benefit' Concert 1982)
Though casual fans are better off with the 'King Biscuit' or 'Hammersmith' gigs, this late period set stuffed with rarely heard material is better still for the collector. The year 1982 was something of a lost one for the band who only released two singles and no albums that year so it's nice to have a look at how good the band were live in this period. Eric is in great voice, is much more comfortable as a frontman (he sticks stage front and often sings rather than plays during this gig for the first time). Some of the performances he turns in here beat the records - especially a gorgeous 'Lying Here With You' that sounds far more heartfelt and emotional than the studio take on 'Ten Out Of Ten' or 'The Power Of Love' which loses that silly reggae-jive it had as a single and turns into quite a stirring rock song. 'Feel The Benefit' also sounds particularly hot played by a band who are clearly on it - it's arguably the best of the many versions around, including the original on 'Deceptive Bends'. Throughout the show, as well as Eric, the stars are Rick Fenn who passes up his usual guitar to contribute some excellent piano (usually played by Eric) and fellow Mancunian Vic Emerson of Sad Cafe (that's his own band's T-shirt he's wearing!) whose synth playing is a cut above that which plagued the last few 10cc records (and again usually played by Eric). There are problems - Graham gets barely anything to do ('Dreadlock Holiday' is his only lead vocal) and the 'oldies' in the set have sounded better (particularly ''Mandy', who never sounded too good live but who sounds positively sick here). All in all though this is another fine show by 10cc and another performance that desperately needs a first release on DVD (it would make a great three-fer-one set alongside the earlier 'Hammersmith' and later 'Rotterdam' show!)

33. Six-Fifty Five Special ('Run Away' 'Dreadlock Holiday' UK TV 1982)
The band are back to sing the same new song 'Run Away' on the Pebble Mill spin-off, which was generally filmed in the courtyard outside the special 'Mill' set (except when it rained!) Eric looks a bit daft singing in the dark with his shades on (even if it is partly to protect his eyes after ongoing problems from his car crash three years before) and he messes up his miming a few times, but no matter - this sweet understated song still sounds good. 'Dreadlock Holiday' is much the same, only Graham is much more animated and doesn't wear sunglasses! Jonathan King was a fellow guest and briefly reminisced about 'discovering' the band- though sadly he gets cut off far too early!

34. Saturday Superstore ('Run Away' UK TV 1982)
The group really went to town plugging this song didn't they? A shame it didn't sell. This time they're on a children's TV show which is a little more chaotic than 'Multi-Coloured Swap Shop' (and that wasn't exactly slick!) The performance is much the same as all the others, with no real banter between hosts and guests.

35. Oomachasooma (Feel The Love) (Music Video 1983)
The band's last album 'Windows In The Jungle' sank without trace and really deserves a re-appraisal containing as it does some of Eric's sharpest and most heartfelt material. This lead-off single, though, was the closest thing to a 'joke' and the 'wacky humour' of old and is well served by a video that's actually a very important and under-rated one in 10cc history. This was directed by Godley and Creme, already big names in the music video business, and while they don't appear in it or play on it both audio and visuals share their characteristic touch. Picking up on the 'love' theme this song is performed at a tennis match (the score for 'nought' in French), but it's madder even than the five set epic between Isner and Mahut in 2010 (70-68 in the fifth and final set!) Graham and Eric (with sunglasses back on) sit in the audience surrounded by extras who seem to have wondered out of a sauna, while the boy and girl playing tennis come up with a series of unlikely looking CGI tennis shots as their romance gets more and more desperate ('It's a million to one that you should find your right girl!') The girl wins by the way, even though she's barely playing and the boy is giving his all - is this a comment akin to Godley-Creme's similar songs about marital troubles in this 'Birds Of Prey' period? Funniest moment by far: the guitar solo, which is mimed by the entire audience on air guitar - and the players on tennis rackets - while Eric and Graham continue to stare out ahead, masters of the poker face. One of the better 10cc promos - certainly the most bonkers!

36. Pebble Mill ('Oomachasooms (Feel The Love)' UK TV 1983)
The band are back for more I-know-you-like-dogs-so-here's-an-item-about-a-hedgehog banter with the Pebble Mill hosts. This time 10cc are out in the open air and they turn in a far more accomplished (albeit still mimed) performance of this quirky song. Someone seems to have told Eric that the camera is up in a tree as he strains his neck looking 'up' even though the camera is 'below' him while the wind ruffles his hair something awful. Still a good clip though. That's Rick in bright green and Paul in bright yellow alongside Eric and Graham - the 1980s have really arrived by now! Included in both the 'Tenology' and 'Changing Faces' sets.

37. Top Pop #5 ('Food For Thought' Holland TV 1983)
A final return to Holland where 10cc perform under moody blue lighting and a girl stops by a table to eat ('Food For Thought' geddit?!), enters a boxing ring (?!) and dances in a 3D cardboard cut out of a door (less easy to understand: did the Top Pop producers mishear the album as 'Door in the Jungle'?!?) Eric is sitting down throughout this clip (was he still bad after his car crash?) and is noticeably reluctant to look at his bandmates, who in turn aren't looking at him. This really feels like the 'end' in retrospect.

38. Rock Around The Clock: 10cc Live In Rotterdam ('Wall Street Shuffle' 'City Lights' 'Oomachasooma/Feel The Love' 'Lying Here With You' 'Dreadlock Holiday' 'I'm Not In Love' 'Working Girls' 'Food For Thought' 'From Rochdale To Ocho Rios' Concert 1983)
The final entry of the 'original' 10cc and all the fun seems to have gone out of the band. This is easily their weakest gig out on video/TV (although the 'Alive' tour of 1992, out on DVD in the 2000s, is arguably even worse). The band play underneath that fuzzy purple 'n' pink  strobe lighting particularly common to rock shows of this vintage (Pink Floyd's 'Delicate Sound Of Thunder' gig is similarly afflicted). Despite the presenter popping up every few minutes to tell us 'what a great time we're all having' the mood feels flat - the band aren't in tune in all meanings of the phrase, Eric and Graham are still ignoring each other, there's just one rather basic 'conversation' with the audience 'at home and around the world' and the band have just lost that slickness and tightness they once had. Even the only chance to hear the 'Windows' material in concert is a lost opportunity - 'City Lights' is filled with mistakes galore, 'Feel The Love' is tentative and wobbly, 'Working Girls' frankly doesn't work and 'Food For Thought' leaves so much food for thought you'd starve. The oldies don't fare much better either, with only another lovely 'Lying Here With You' standing out and even that was performed better in Wembley the year before. Once again Graham gets the short straw with only 'Dreadlock' and 'Rochdale' to sing (plus a couple of lines on 'City Lights'), although it's good to see Vic Emerseon still adding his subtle synth to the arrangements. The end result is far from terrible - 10cc can still play well even on an offday and their material is still top-notch - but you can tell the heart has gone out of the band and that retirement is the only answer. That really is it until the reunion - be strong, big boys don't cry...

39. Woman In Love (Music Video 1992)
A weird promo, especially for a 'comeback' album which doesn't even feature 10cc for the most part, just some random sepia tinged shots of people walking through a town centre. This song is called 'Woman In Love' not 'Woman walks randomly down a few streets and does some shopping'! Even when we do see Eric and Graham they're in black and white and not really responding much to the camera. Included in the 'Tenology' set where it makes for a very sorry finale, even if its chronologically accurate as the last promo there.

40. Countdown ('Woman In Love' Holland TV 1992)
'Top Pop' may have gone but 10cc's love affair with Dutch TV networks continues with the only 'live' TV performance of the reunion era. The band sound a little bit fragile and the mix is a little rough (Graham's harmonies cutting in and out) but it's the only live recording of any of the 'new' reunion songs so for that we must be grateful. Well kinda - have you heard the reunion material?!

41. ('I'm Not In Love' Holland TV 1995)
You wouldn't know it from Graham's chatty demeanour but he and Eric have had a huge row and are no longer working together but separately - actually you might guess that from the silent guitarist scowling behind his sunglasses! The duo only played together on this one song, which as Graham says was intended as a one-off for a TV broadcast but record label Mercury asked it to be put on the album instead. Very nice it sounds too - the folkier, simpler, 'unplugged' version of 'I'm Not In Love' makes up in simple purity what it lacks in groundbreaking synthesised 'aaaahs'. As Graham puts it, the band have always had a special place in their hearts for Holland, so it's a fitting place to end this list. We move on to Godley and Creme after the break though, so stay tuned after this advertisement!...
42. Consequences (News Report and Cinema Advert 1977)
...For Godley-Creme's 'Consequences' which really was broadcast in cinemas in 1977 (before the first 'Star Wars' according to one of my sources!) Rightly figuring that most rock and pop fans wouldn't have a clue what the hell the triple-album debut was all about - and wrongly figuring film-goers might - this promo features lots of Peter Cook, random shots of destruction and devastation and and actually rather good superimposition of the album cover logo in the sky as a big ol' 'face' made out of clouds. As the narrator put it Consequences 'began as a gizmo and ended up in a blaze of musical energy', so there.  Three whole minutes is a bit much though, even a fan like me would have been tutting into his popcorn by the end. Picking up on the idea 10cc also plugged their 'Live and Let Live' album in cinemas shortly afterwards, though this short thirty second advert just features grainy shots of Eric singing 'I'm Not In Love' 'People In Love' 'Good Morning Judge' and 'I'm Mandy, Fly Me'. It 'comes from the heart' apparently - are you sure the narrator didn't mean 'bank balance'?! Back to Godley-Creme for a new item which features the duo walking around the outside of Strawberry Studios for a bit and a patronising reminder what the 'gizmo' is. Lol then gives a demonstration of 'the ultimate sustain' and plays along to a snatch of the 'Consequences' album. The string-bending device was on the market for £70 at the time apparently - more than all but the best guitars back then! Sounds like a fiddle to me - and a horn and a harmonica and a flute...

43. 5 O'Clock In The Morning (TOTP 1977)
Godley-Creme's first TOTP appearance shows just how respected they still were a year after the split with 10cc - this single didn't chart and is one of the few non-charting songs to ever be performed on TOTP. Lol looks good, singing and playing as if he's still the starry front-man, but a wild-haired Kevin looks as if he hasn't slept in weeks and leans nonchalantly on the piano. Nice performance all the same though. Warning: the beginning of this clip contains Jimmy Saville, which sadly means we'll never see it on BBC4's TOTP repeats worse luck...

44. An Englishman In New York (Music Video 1978)
Demented mannekins staggering round the block, deformed lyrics poured over clockwork rolling stock, Guggenheim attitudes back to back with vaudeville rock, this is Godley-Creme at their strangest and/or most groundbreaking. Lol winds up and conducts the orchestra of no less than fourteen working robot dummies (they don't look powerful to take over the world, but equally they achieve a lot for 1978 standards) while Godley sings (miming to the 'earlier' of the two phased vocals if you're wondering). This must have confused the hell out of most people and scared the rest, but once seen never forgotten...Included on the 'Changing Faces' set.

45. Wide Boy (Music Video 1980)
Considering it was made on a budget of about 50p and in a set that's deliberately so small you keep noticing bits being recycled over and over, this video is awfully good and just as pioneering as 'New York' but in a very different way. Godley looks the part of a new waver on a track that always sounded like Madness (both senses of the word) as he walks up and down corridors looking cross and - later - walks through a 'picture' of the duo and later still a smoke alarm (the theme: nothing is what you think it is). This is surely where 'West Wing' got their 'corridor' obsession from, if only CJ had worn a pin-striped suit and had stubble and wild hairdo.

46. Under Your Thumb (Music Video/TOTP 1981)
Both the video and TOTP appearance of this hit are virtually identical - Godley jerks around like a robot while Creme 'pretends' to be steering the mad twinkling synth. A bit of a disappointment given how visual this song about suicide and escape is.

47. Wedding Bells (Music Video/TOTP 1981)
This promo, though, is hilarious. Acknowledging the tongue-in-cheek gospel/Motown flavour of the song, Godley and Creme hire two dancers and a choreographer and put together a dance move that both spoofs and shames boy bands the world over from every era. Godley and Creme are, of course, the last artists who should ever be doing this sort of thing and that's what makes it so funny - especially with the pair's deadpan expressions! The 'square peg in a round hole...don't need a fanfare or a drum-roll' verse is so spot-on you start t wonder if the pair wrote this song around their planned dance sequence! The same quartet also put together a near foot-perfect performance on TOTP. Included on the 'Changing Faces' set.

48. Save A Mountain For Me (Music Video 1983)
'Jailhouse Rock' without the props, shot in arty monochrome and with Godley 'pretending' to be doing hard labour. Actually it's the listener doping hard labour as this squeaky repetitive song wasn't one of their better ideas and nor is this rarely seen promo one of their good ones. At least Godley looks the part of a scarred ruffian inmate and is very convincing, as is Creme leading a Rubber Bullets style 'riot' armed with a mop!

49. Golden Boy (Music Video 1984)
A fascinating video for a fascinating song, which spins a new meaning on the idea of '3D'! A video plays - normal so far - but we actually get to 'see' the video going round in the slot, while Godley, Creme and two backing singers appear 'projected' out the lid and go round and round at the same speed. Only they're flat one-dimensional characters joined at the neck, while below the duo lark about in some gold tinsel. At one point during the instrumental break the tape snaps and starts flying around before finally calming down and going back into its box. A most criminally under-rated work, both single and video, this is even better on both accounts than the better-known 'Cry'. Included on the 'Changing Faces' set.

50. Cry (Music Video 1985)
Talking of which, Godley-Creme's most famous moment is this camera-panning masterpiece. Having written a song that was unusually 'universal' by Godley-Creme standards, the duo wanted a video that was similarly 'universal' and came up with the idea of everybody round the world singing the song, regardless of creed, colour, gender or age (or species! Gonzo from The Muppets is in there too and he's a well, you know a whatever). They went through a book of extras hiring those with distinctive faces, stuck them in a chair with a tight zoom lock on it (and everyone's heads stuck in the back of a frying pan out of shot to keep them in line) and the duo then edited the track and 'morphed' it. The elder gentlemen who sobs at the end wasn't the great bit of acting everyone thinks by the way - he was one of the last to be filmed when the shoot had already done over budget and deadline and he hadn't learnt the two lines everyone had been asked to memorise and sing. The directors lost it and shouted in frustration and the tears you see are real! Much talked about for a reason, 'Cry' is special in many ways and much loved for a reason. The big finale of the 'Changing Faces' video, though you have to sit through ten minutes of nonsense via the 'History Mix' first.

51. History Mix (Music Video 1985)
Talking of which, do you remember everyone talking about how The Beatles 'Love' album/mis-mash was so groundbreaking years ago even though true fans knew a) other bands had done it before and b) the idea was inspired by a bunch of Beatle bootleggers (who to be honest did it better)? Well this is one of the earliest examples of 'sampling' as Godley and Creme celebrate twenty years of friendship and music-making with a collage of sounds taken from all periods of their career (though sadly not 'Frabjoy and the Runciple Spoon'). The video has the same idea and throws bits and pieces together willy nilly whether they fit or not and not always from 10cc/Godley-Creme (basically any video the pair directed and could afford the rights to and they did a lot!) - the result is a headache, but at least it's a pioneering headache. The problem for collectors is there is some genuinely fascinating material in there, such as 'Light Me Up!', based around a storming loop of an Eric Stewart guitar solo taken from an otherwise unseen performance of 'Second Sitting For The Last Supper'. And what do we get as visuals over the top after a few seconds? A mannequin telling us 'big boys don't cry' and some girls wrestling in mud from a Duran Duran video shoot to the sound of orgasmic grunts (which is no substitute at all and a lot less erotic than it sounds). Although that said it's great to see Police's 'Every Breath You Take' on fast forward, which is easily the best way to see it - that made my day! A mess, seen in all its unedited glory towards the end of 'Changing Faces'.

52. A Little Piece Of Heaven (Music Video 1988)
Picking up on the tongue-in-cheek style of the lyric, this is another 'Wedding Bells' that parodies all cheesy late 1980s videos where people walk down random streets strumming guitars (even ex-Beatles weren't immune; Paul McCartney does exactly this in 'Hope Of Deliverance' and that was five years afterwards!) Along the way the duo get interrupted by six (count 'em) harmonica players and three backing singers in the days before they formed 'Londonbeat' together. The result is a bit of an oddball, not sarcastic enough really for people who didn't know the duo didn't always look and sound like that.

53. 10,000 Angels (Music Video 1988)
The very final music video is a little disappointing too - gimmicky digital effects added onto Godley and Creme miming the song. The twist is that the pair must be sitting on fans as their hair shoots right up into the sky - and Godley's has never been longer in this period - until their hair final goes back to normal on the final note. So ends the final time these two are seen together.

54. Mondo Video (Indescribable, 1988)
I spent a fortune on this video - and from a charity shop as well! - and I still don't know what to make of it. This isn't a music video so much as an art installation that's clearly meant to mean something, but goodness knows what. We start with a ringing alarm clock, move on to a minute's worth of cigarette smoke twirling in the air, watch cuts of Creme playing individual notes on a piano shot from above, a close-up of Creme's guitar bubbles bursting in the air over violin frets and speeded-up shots of Godley on the drums. The end result is fifteen minutes of my life I will never get back and is the Godley-Creme video catalogue equivalent of similarly impenetrable second album 'L', although we might have thought less of them if they hadn't tried something so ridiculously outrageous, stuck it out on home video and charged a tenner for it. Erm, I think! In case you were wondering 'mondo' is an archaic expression meaning 'strikingly unique' and 'that there is nothing else of its kind'. You can say that again!


The Best Unreleased Recordings: 

Not much unreleased material for you this book I'm afraid - 10cc kept a notoriously tight lock on their outtakes and works in progress and as a self-contained unit (who usually didn't employ producers or even an engineer) there are few opportunities for stuff to 'leak'. The only 'famous' 10cc outtake 'Voodoo Boogie' (an early version of 'People In Love' with dafter lyrics) is also out officially now on the 'Tenology' set so bang goes the entry for the only outtake every committed fan 'knows'. There are a half dozen interesting exceptions though, even if we've had to dodge what actually constitutes a '10cc recording' in a few cases...

1.    Tallyman (Graham Gouldman song for Herman's Hermits, 1968)
Graham had a close relationship with Peter Noone and provided the band with two of their biggest hits with 'No Milk Today' and 'Pamela Pamela'. By 1968 though both halves are losing their commercial touch (Graham hasn't had a hit in two years) and both are trying to break out of their 'mould'. 'Tallyman' is a weird psychedelic song about a lucky mascot which Herman's Hermits rejected as a single but did once sing on a BBC session. The tallyman 'survives to the end so we made him a friend', which is sweet but rather confusing. Not as distinctive as Graham's usual work but it's easy to imagine him singing it somehow.

2.    Gizmotron Demonstration Record (Godley-Creme c.1974)

Not that Godley or Creme were obsessed or anything, buy they thought the public ought to hear more about their wonderful new stringbending effect which was coming to all shops soon. So we get bored announcer Lol interrupting creative genius Lol trying to make a guitar sound like a violin or a hammer or a mellotron - given that we're listening to this on a flexi-disc for all we know Lol really is playing this on a violin or a hammer or a mellotron! I'm not sure I'm convinced, especially given that the demonstration lasts six whole minutes. The end snippet is nice though, a band 'jam' (in truth mutliple Godleys and Cremes) that sounds a lot more convincing and musical than most of the similar early 10cc B-sides. Maybe I will gizmo this way after all...It's a surprise this interesting snippet hasn't appeared on CD yet, perhaps as an extra on the pricey 'Consequences' sets so we can all have another six minute sequence of nonsense to skip.

3. I'm Not In Love (with unreleased bridge, 1975)
Perhaps the most interesting still-an-outtake of all, this is 'I'm Not In Love' as it existed right up to the eleventh hour with everything intact. Even a bridge that the band thought wasn't working so they simply removed Eric's vocal and left it as an instrumental (it's the dreamy bit just before 'Big Boys Don't Cry'). The missing lyrics run as follows: 'It's because...Don't feel let down, don't get hung up, we do what we can, do what we want....' No it doesn't really fit does it? The band were probably right to drop it!

4. Man In A Suitcase (Demo of 'From Rochdale To Ocho Rios' 1978)
There really aren't many 10cc demos that still exist, only Graham's jolly but tinny 'Bloody Tourists' song. The song sounds much cuter in basic form even if all it features is Graham and a synthesiser. Graham hasn't got many of the verses yet but he's already 'mapped out' his chorus and its list of destinations and Eric gets to yell the chorus in a much greasier rockier way than he veer did on record.

5. Yvonne's The One (McCartney-Stewart demo 1986)
When 10cc split up, Eric's first gig was to join Paul McCartney's band (you can see him in the ill-fated 'Give My Regards To Broad Street' film). Together the pair wrote half of the under-rated 1986 McCartney album 'Press To Play' (very recommended to those with 10cc styles of humour!), an album which also spawned two Eric-Macca co-writes that didn't make the album. Demos exist for both of them with Paul singing which we're going to speak about here - for Eric singing the pretty 'Yvonne' (complete with calypso drums) seek out the 1995 10cc reunion album 'Mirror Mirror'. The demo is far superior though, with a golden McCartney falsetto treating the song as ballad rather than rocker and telling the sad tale of a girl 'where sadness came into her life'. The narrator loves her from a distance but she runs around with other boys so he sadly says 'so long Yvonne'. Had Eric sung this lovely track the way Paul does here (they do have similar falsettos) it would have been a highlight of the 'Mirror' CD instead of yet another track hat didn't quite work.

6. Don't Break The Promises (McCartney-Stewart demo 1986)
Similarly, the McCartney demo and 10cc band recording (for 1992's 'Meanwhile...' this time) also couldn't have been more different, though this time Eric's remake is marginally better. In truth this isn't a great song in either version: this time it's McCartney who turns to reggae to make a point (in fact it's a surprise the Stewart-McCartney songs aren't all reggae given their shared love for the genre) and uses a tinny drum machine and lots of echo to sing a not-very-noteworthy song about trust and betrayal whilst sounding like Michael Jackson. On Eric's version he sounds more like a slowed down Billy Joel, emoting with everything he's got, but neither version quite cuts it by 10cc's high standards. 



That's all for this week! The first of our Who columns should be starting next week as it's goodbye to 10cc. See you then! 


A NOW COMPLETE LIST OF 10cc ARTICLES TO READ AT ALAN’S ALBUM ARCHIVES:





'How Dare You!' (1976) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2014/08/10cc-how-dare-you-1976.html




'Meanwhile' (1992) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2015/09/10cc-meanwhile-1992.html

'Mirror Mirror' (1995) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.nl/2016/09/10cc-mirror-mirror-1995.html

Pre-10cc: 1965-1973, A Guide to Mindbenders, Mockingbirds and Frabjoy and Runciple Spoon!



Non-Album Songs Part One 1972-1980 https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/07/10cc-non-album-songs-part-one-1972-1980.html


Non-Album Songs Part Two 1981-2006 https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/07/10cc-non-album-songs-part-two-1981-2006.html

Surviving TV Clips, Music Videos and Unreleased Recordings https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/08/10cc-and-godley-creme-surviving-tv.html


Solo/Wax/Live/Compilation Albums Part One 1971-1986

https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/08/10cc-solocompilationlivewax-albums-part.html


Solo/Wax/Live/Compilation Albums Part Two 1987-2014 https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/08/10cc-sololivecompilationwax-albums-part.html

Landmark Concerts and Cover Versions http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com/2018/07/10cc-five-landmark-concerts-and-three.html


10cc Essay: Not-So-Rubber Bullets http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com/2018/06/10cc-essay-not-so-rubber-bullets.html

Monday, 14 August 2017

The Searchers "Hungry Hearts" (1989)



You can now buy 'Once Upon A Time - The Alan's Album Archives Guide To The Music Of The Searchers' in e-book form by clicking here







The Seachers “Hungry Hearts” (1989)

Forever In Love/Love Lies Bleeding/Lonely Weekend/Somebody Told Me/Every Little Tear/Sweets For My Sweet ‘88/No Other Love/This Boy’s In Love/Fooled Myself Once Again/Baby I Do/Push Push/Needles and Pins ‘88

Welcome, dear readers, to one of the most obscure albums on this website. First up the bad news: like many a Hollies album it was only ever released in Germany (a country where they seem to have particularly good music tastes it has to be said). It was only ever released once, back in 1989 which is – gulp – ever so nearly thirty years ago so your odds of finding it are (how can I put this?) slim at best. At the current time of writing it is currently priced at just under £40 on Amazon and costs even more on Ebay. And do you really want to be paying that price for an album that, as well as being one of our most obscure, is also one of the most 1980s, with not just one synthesiser playing on most tracks but about half-a-dozen of the little blighters all doing their own thing and drowning out the Searchers sound. Not that there is much of a ‘Searchers sound’ on this record – this is the only one the band have so far made after losing founding member, lead singer and guitar player Mike Pender who left the band to, ahh, ‘search’ for his own solo fame somewhere in the mid-1980s. That’s the bad news – the good news is that, if by chance you happen to somehow comes across a copy (or maybe if they re-release it one day?) what you are getting is just enough of that Searchers style to make your time worthwhile. And this is, after all, a band who never did release many records – the thought of owning one eighth of a band’s album releases is enough to make more than just obsessive monkeynuts anorak-wearing collectors want to search for it. And it all makes sense that The Searchers should make us search for their complete catalogue doesn’t it?

What you get on the weirdly titled ‘Hungry Hearts’ isn’t that far removed from the ‘other’ releases in the ‘Hearts’ trilogy – 1979’s ‘The Searchers’ (which has a lot of song about hearts on it) and 1981’s ‘Hearts In Their Eyes’. The Searchers have ignored most of their Chris Curtis-driven mid-1960s experimentation and gone straight back to being what they were in 1963: practitioners of contemporary pop with an emphasis on jingly-jangly guitars. There’s nothing that groundbreaking here and nothing as timeless as was heard in the 1960s. But The Searchers always had good taste and that never changes in any era: most of their cover songs are solid choices (shame they don’t write more of their own stuff though) and they instinctively understand what the period is all about (this time round everything sounds BIG, like the songs are wearing shoulder-pads) far more than many of their still-struggling 1960s contemporaries do. As with their new wave albums it’s not that much of a stretch to imagine The Searchers in this brave new world of synths and electronics and if you were a teenager back in 1989 and you heard this album on the radio (if you were German, perhaps, the only country that ever really heard it) then you would probably be hard pressed to guess that it was made by a bunch of musicians who were probably older than your own parents. If I have to listen to late 1980s pop by anyone for the rest of my life then – dear God – shoot me now, but failing that The Searchers would probably be my pick: they get the feel, the vibe, the tone, the air of arrogance and surfaceness that went along with everything in that era from Madonna to The Backstreet Boys. In a way thank goodness there was never a mid-1990s Searchers album because if there was then I can guarantee they’d all be doing a pretty good impression of The Spice Girls too!

New fans who don’t know much about The Searchers are well catered for then. But what about older fans? This one is a harder sell, mostly for reasons outside the band’s control. They have for this new album a new lead singer in Spencer James. He was a new boy back in 1989 and he was in rather a unique position amongst 1960s acts, at least until Carl Wayne and then Peter Howarth took over lead singing duties for The Hollies in the 21st century: how do you replace a frontman whose been established for decades not just years and everyone expects to see? Odd to say it, but Spencer has now been a Searcher for a decade longer than Mike Pender ever was and about six times longer than Chris Curtis was in the band and yet this is the only studio album we have to judge his talents on, recorded back when he was still a youngster learning the ropes and settling into his Searchers duties. It’s a real shame this band haven’t given us an album since because you suspect he’d make a much better job of it now he has the confidence and his own sizeable fanbase to back him up – but back in 1989 he sounds a little unsure of himself and uncomfortable, somewhere between doing a Mike Pender parody and singing with his own excellent vocals. Sometimes he comes across as a little OTT and cod-operatic (‘Somebody Told Me’ is dreadful, like a combination of Freddie Mercury and Montserrat Caballe singing in the same body – it even sounds a bit like ‘Barcelona’). Sometimes he sounds like exactly what The Searchers need in 1989 – a singer of range and versatility who sounds utterly at home in the period setting (‘No Other Love’) and you sense he’s only just starting to get the hang of this recording lark as the album sessions were over. Overall though he does as good a job as anyone can of replacing an established twenty-two-year-career singer and still making the part his own (it doesn’t help that his higher-pitched vocals don’t sound anything like Mike’s).

I’m surprised in retrospect how few reminders there of the Searchers sound in here just to make the connection between old fans that bit more obvious. Frank Allen gets the odd voc al here and there (‘Every Little Tear’ and ‘Baby I Do’, which oddly enough are as retro as you’d expect…but for the ‘wrong’ decade, sounding very 1950s-ish again like a few songs from ‘Hearts In Their Eyes’. The ‘Grease’ ship that made that decade popular again had sailed long ago by 1989). But that’s about it: there are relatively few cases of those famous Searchers harmonies (a shame given that when Frank and Spencer do sing together it pretty much sounds terrific). There’s precious little of John McNally’s wonderful jingly-jangly guitar (and when you do hear it the sound is buried underneath an avalanche of synths). And there are no flashbacks or throwbacks to The Searchers’ illustrious past – well, with two exceptions. We’re used to hearing The Searchers updating their old hits for a new audience. They did it in the early 1970s, they still do this in concert today, but here in 1989 (with both recordings dubbed ’88 because that’s when they were made and released as a single before being added to this album) they sound particularly odd. Would the 1988 remake of ‘Needles and Pins’ have been as big a hit? Probably not – the song is as great as ever and the guitar riff is a classic, but all those synths are hard to take and Spencer sounds far less comfortable as a Mike Pender-clone than he does sounding like himself. And ‘Sweets For My Sweet ‘88’ is actually worse, The Searchers’ silliest hit now beefed up with quirky synths and fake drums that sounds more like a punishment for old fans for living into middle age than a genuine attempt to reinvent the wheel. Thankfully the Searchers continued to do both songs ‘properly’ live in this period, which would have made for a far more useful bonus feature. One wonder what they thought they were trying to do: these recordings sound too yesteryear to appeal to new fans and too hideously modern to please their old ones.

The real gems on the record come from the parts when The Searchers pick up on the best of their previous two albums and present an older, wiser face to us despite the continual rather desperately ‘yoof’ sound of the LP. There’s a neat theme here of being betrayed and abandoned and the narrator’s vows that they’re not going to let this happen to them again, ev-uh. The ‘secret theme’ of this record is that life is too short to settle for second-best, even if the ‘immediate sound’ of this album is ‘hey, we’re young, life’s great, let’s party!’ which makes for an interesting dichotomy that probably only the secretly trendy Searchers could have pulled off. ‘Forever In Love’ is about how you can never forget someone you fell in love with, even if circumstances mean things never quite work out. ‘Love Lies Bleeding’ is about how awful it can feel to lose the one you love after thinking it would last forever. Album highlight ‘Lonely Weekend’ tires of having to go through quite so many empty nights in a half-relationship that neither partner quite means. ‘Don’t waste my time’ sighs Spencer with the weariness of a singer twice his age. ‘Every Little Tear’ remembers every detail decades later as the narrator, now older and wiser, worries about how he behaved back in his youth when he didn’t know any better. ‘No Other Love’ worries that a past romance was the one that was meant to be in their life and that they’re now doomed to a life of loneliness. ‘This Boy’s In Love (For The First Time)’ is actually about finding love late in life – only after finding someone he can adore the way his peers did decades ago does a narrator finally admit that all his previous loves weren’t really ‘the ones’ and he was only keeping up appearances. ‘Fooled Myself Once Again’ though makes it clear how desperate the narrator is to believe that after so many years of living alone. ‘Baby I Do’ is another guilty song about missing someone that you treated badly and hoping that you will make it up one day. And ‘Push Push’ is about the rows and arguments that drive couples apart, but which can equally be pushed out the way if you really want to be together, rather than being used as an ‘excuse’ to part. This is, in terms of lyrics, the most grown-up set of songs The Searchers ever performed outside the ‘Take Me For What I’m Worth’ album fourteen years earlier, each one (the 1960s re-treads aside) concerned with older narrators looking back on their past and working out where it went wrong and vowing to do better next time. The sound, though, screams being young and youthful and teenage and living in the moment – it’s an interesting combination, with the songs for this record clearly chosen with care.

The ‘problem’ is that this record is one that would only have worked at the time – to everyone else whose come to this album since 1989 it sounds painful. That period doesn’t scream ‘contemporary trendy pop’ to us anymore, it screams ‘mistakes we shouldn’t have made from our past’ which means that ‘Hungry Hearts’ is never going to be quite as successful as it would have sounded at the time. Instead of slipping older words of advice to a young audience it now sounds like The Searchers were mutton dressed as lamb who should have known better than to swamp everything with quite so many synthesisers. It sounds now as if The Searchers were part of the problem, not the solution: that they were just falling in the same trap as everyone else of trying desperately to look young and trendy and coming out of it looking a bit stupid – especially now that the youngsters of the day are no longer young and trendy themselves (and are, worryingly, older now than The Searchers would have been at the time). Somehow you can’t imagine the Backstreet Boys and Bros of this world re-uniting and adding a hip hop backbeat to their music, which makes The Searchers’ a particularly unique experiment, matched only by their attempts at new wave.

Another contradiction in this album is that the songs seem to have been chosen with care (all of them fitting the album ‘theme’, whether consciously or not) but at the same time seem to have been arranged and recorded in something of a rush. There are four producers credited for this album who all worked on their own three or four songs at different dates snatched between Searchers tourdates in Germany that year – never a good sign of a cohesive LP. My ‘favourites’ are produced by Tony Hendrik, best known for co-writing Haddaway hit single ‘What Is Love?’ and his own 1970 hit single ‘The Grooviest Girl In Town’. A relative contemporary of The Searchers, he ‘gets’ their need to sound young without losing their middle-aged-ness much more than the others who struggle slightly and overcook the synthesisers. Other producers include Theo Werdin from German heavy metal band ‘Vatra’, Hans Steignen who ended up a German film composer in later life and the singer ‘Levy’ (who has only recently found big fame now he’s the age The Searchers were then, with the album ‘Rotten Love’ starting a string of hits from 2005 onwards). What’s interesting is that The Searchers worked with such a range of producers – big names, little names, trendy names, not-yet-famous names, all of them German. However none of their producers ever meddle with their sound – there are no German-language songs on this album, no local hip and trendy German bands stuck randomly over the top and very little sense that this album has been made effectively a long way from home. Which is a good move I think: the German market wanted another Searchers album sounding the way they always did, just a little bit more contemporary if possible, and they got it.

This remains, however, the weakest Searchers album of the eight for all sorts of understandable reasons. Spencer James if a fine vocalist and is, if you see him in concert today, a fine Searchers vocalist who makes those old songs his own – but that wasn’t true back in 1989 when he made this record as the first new member of the band in two decades or so. The two re-treads especially sound like a horrid drunken pub tribute act rather than a true Searchers recording. All Searchers albums cling proudly to the year in which they were made and the fact that this one was made in such a God-awful period for music makes listening to it in any year after around 1990 painful to swallow. The songs are good for progressing the album theme of ‘I wish I knew what I know now when I was younger’ (to quote fellow AAA star Ronnie Lane) but aren’t really that distinctive and song by song are easily the weakest selection the band ever did (even though there are lots of highlights, particularly ‘Lonely Weekend’ which is impressively ahead of its times and ‘Baby I Do’, which is impressively behind them). This album lacks the sheer pizzaz and energy of the band’s new wave records from 1979 and 1981 which did, I think, supplement The Searchers’ more natural attack that much better. Given the ridiculous price this album currently costs to buy, you’re probably better off saving your money for something else – like eight books from the AAA series we’re still vaguely hoping to print next year, the Searchers box set ‘Hearts In Their Eyes’ or enough money to pay for the air miles to travel to both Donald Trump and Theresa May to slap them round the back of the head and say ‘what the hell do you think you’re doing? The people have spoken – go now, do not pass go, do not collect £20000, go fade into obscurity the way you deserve!’

‘Hungry Hearts’ remains, however, simultaneously a deeply under-rated album. Nobody paid much attention to it when it came out, even in Germany. No one seems to have even considered re-releasing it even though The Searchers have a whole new growing fanbase in this day and age who’d love to hear it at a price they can actually afford. Due, I suspect, mostly because of licensing rights, this album gets ignored almost every single time The Searchers release one of their quadruple-yearly ‘greatest hit’ sets (the opening track ‘Forever In Love’ and the horrific ‘Needles and Pins ‘88’ are the only two songs you have any chances of hearing). ‘Hungry Hearts’ isn’t a classic, no, but it deserves one hell of a lot better than the obscurity and limbo it currently walks in. The Searchers remain a terrific under-rated band and if this is as low as they fall then, well, that’s still pretty high – unlike most of their contemporaries they really do ‘get’ how to make this music and have the songs to back them up. I just wish there had been a tiny bit more of the ‘old’ Searchers sound on here too in order to make it easier for us fans to navigate as well.

‘Forever In Love’ is perhaps not the best place to start. Imagine the most 1980s sound you’ve ever heard in your life. Maybe Guns and Roses backing Madonna on a Stock-Aitken-Waterman production with Kylie Minogue and Jason Donovan dancing. Quadruple it. That still isn’t enough warning for how 1980s this soppy synth-fest is going to be. Clearly The Searchers are being ‘relevant’ here and yet what’s odd is that there’s not one note on this opening track that sounds anything like the Searchers of old – along with the new vocalist (and Spencer James tried hard but really isn’t this sort of a vocalist) there’s nothing here that remotely sounds the way the band did on their last recordings in 1981, never mind the 1960s. That’s a shame because, in another parallel universe, this could have been quite a fun Searchers song – it’s about undying devotion which was always a big Searchers theme and could have sounded good with some Rickenbacker guitars. Performed like this though the song is just too soppy, too synth-based that you need to cut through eleven pairs of shoulder-pads and endless synth work to work out whether the song is worth your while paying attention to – and, really, it isn’t. What’s more the song isn’t even that original but seems to have been ripped off Chris De Burgh’s ‘Lady In Red’ – and when a song you write is ripped off one of the worst songs in history and yet doesn’t even sound that good, you know you’ve got problems. One of the worst horrors on the album and indeed in this book. Horrid.

Good luck if you managed to get through that last song without choking. Luckily ‘Love Lies Bleeding’ is your reward and as anonymous as it is, at least it sounds like a song that The Searchers should be doing. The muscly backing kinda sounds like Merseybeat if you shut your eyes, there’s a fun descending riff that’s kinda creepy (though typically for the period it loses a lot of its impact played on a synth on the ‘twinkly’ setting’ and there’s a typically Searcher-esque lyric about how love has gone wrong and lies bleeding on the floor. There are even some harmonies on this one and it’s just so good to hear Frank in the vocals again, as proof that The Searchers are in there somewhere. It’s a shame that Frank didn’t sing lead on this song though because this is one of those tracks that needs to strike a bit of a sour note, it’s a dark dangerous creepy journey through love and Spencer, good as he is on straightforward love songs, is less sure of himself on songs like this one. Still there’s a shouty chorus that makes everything (temporarily) sound alright and Billy Adamson celebrates his twentieth anniversary with the band by playing one of his better, boomier drum parts too. Add a few Rickebackers to this lot and I’d be happy.

‘Lonely Weekend’ is by far the album highlight. The Searchers were always good at ballads, but this one gains from having the muscle and might of their Merseybeat days over the top of everything and John McNally’s guitars front and centre where they should be, drowning out the synths for once. Loneliness and despair features in many a Searchers ditty and this one particularly suits the band, as Spencer sounds really good singing about another lonely evening spent on his own with no one to see. He sensibly plays this song cool and light, making out that it’s no biggie, I mean he’s spent every other night alone as well so why not this one too? But oh that backing really offers up a sense of the real despair behind that façade: McNally’s wailing guitar is desperate, angry, snarling, unable to hide the passion at its centre. Even the synth backing works quite well here, with only two of them on this track – one that plays some really sad minor chords a la Rick Wright’s work with Pink Floyd and one that sounds, aptly enough, like a doorbell, as if offering the hope that the narrator’s luck is going to change and he’s going to be surrounded by visitors any minute.  But no, this isn’t that clichéd a song and instead this song is full of lots of drawn out sounds, with ‘ro-o-o-o-om’ now the antithesis of the excitement of ‘When You Walk In The Room’, now turned into a life where no one is going to walk into that room and where the room is in fact trapping the narrator and confining him to a lonely grave. An exquisite song expertly played, this should have been the template for the rest of the record. Good as the song is, see how much better things are when The Searchers get their guitars out of their cases?!

‘Somebody Told Me’ is, alas, the sound of Englebert Humperdinck singing an Andrew Lloyd Webber entry for the Eurovision Song Contest. It’s so cheesy all the supermarkets in France wouldn’t contain as much dairy as this and everybody in the band seems to be going the extra mile to make all this torturous. Spencer is the worst victim, assuming that this slow dramatic weepie is best sung in an OTT slow dramatic voice that borders on the operatic. I’m really not so sure I agree and that goes triple for my ears which are still ringing from playing this song yesterday. However he’s not the only one – the synths are so plodding, the bass work so generic, the drums so tinny, the guitars so weak, that everything adds up to what surely must be the second most depressingly poor song in The Searchers’ catalogue – only next to ‘Forever In Love’ does this song sound good as at least it isn’t obviously ripped off something icky (instead it feels like lots of yukky songs thrown together into a pot and melted into a grey-brown stew). As for the song itself, I’m not sure what it’s trying to say. Not that I play this song very often, but the first few times I thought it was a ‘Please Please Me’ song – a third party song where the narrator was trying to get two friends hitched. But the more I play it and attempt to untangle the words (this is one of the few AAA albums so obscure there isn’t a lyric page dedicated to it on the internet) the more I figure that it’s set a bit after that and is about somebody telling the narrator what the love of his life has been up to since they parted. That might explain why Spencer sounds so miserable singing this song, but it still doesn’t give him a right to frighten all pets within a ten mile radius every time you play this song. Once again horrific, but at least that will be it now for the album’s lesser moments and things get very much better from here.

‘Every Little Tear’ is a fun quirky little song that’s much like Frank’s material from the last two Searchers albums, as he figures – mostly rightly – that the 1980s music scene is just a more elaborate version of the simple pop songs he grew up on in the 1950s. This odd but catchy little song is like two Searchers templates stuck together: we’ve got the bouncy can’t-sit-still rock and roll sort, which sounds mighty good even if for the most part the riffs have been given over to the synths again and not the guitars or bass. And then over the top we’ve got a sad little lyric about how the narrator remembers every little hurt he’s ever been sent which recalls such previous weepies as ‘A Tear Fell’. The two never quite meet up in the middle as well as they should, but it is at least a clever idea with Frank seemingly the only person whose even noticed the hurts and the insults thrown his way as he weeps sadly on one of his two lead vocals on the album in the middle of this song while everyone else parties. This song also makes the single best use of synthesiser on the album as the many quick-flowing notes really do sound like little tear-drops. Though Spencer has the more obvious ‘lead singer’ voice (and is, I suspect, understandably nervous on his first trip inside a recording studio here) Frank is a much more instinctive vocalist and adds a great deal of extra passion and feeling into his work. It’s a real shame the Searchers didn’t give him more space for quirky songs like this after Mike Pender left because this song and ‘Baby I Do’ sound much more obviously Searchers-ish.

The biggest difference in vocals can be heard on ‘Sweets For My Sweet ‘88’, the first of two recycled recordings from the previous year included on this record. Like many a re-recording it’s pointless, bordering on blasphemous, and seems to be here more as a way of conning fans into buying this album to hear a song they might recognise or as an advert for the fact that the touring band still sounds surprisingly close to the real thing, even if most of the new album doesn’t. I do however prefer this version to the re-recording the band made of the song back in 1972. Back then, with only the rhythm section not there for the original recording, it seemed even more pointless, especially slowed down for no apparent reason. This recording is closer to what would have happened if The Searchers had really been a new band in 1988, young and hungry for the current pop dynamics and if nothing else this new arrangement proves how well they understand the pop market of 1988: instead of being direct this version is sly, instead of being pure and innocent it’s slightly knowing, instead of being pure joy it’s all slightly sour, but those harmonies (missing for much of the record) still sound great and the song is still played with bags of energy, unusual for a band who must have been truly sick of playing this song after a quarter century of doing it most shows they ever played. I still don’t get why it’s on this album though where it only shows up how poor most of the band’s material now is (and let’s face it, ‘Sweets For My Sweet’ may have been one of the most successful Searchers songs, but it was never the greatest or deepest track the band ever did. We’ve had three versions of this song now and still Tony Jackson’s breathlessly exciting original is the best by sheer character alone, even if Mike and Spencer may well technically be better vocalists. Though only John McNally played on all three he has less to do on this version than ever before, with a very perfunctory guitar solo, which is a shame. Sweeter than some other recordings perhaps, but not as much of a treat as you suspect it should have been.

‘No Other Love’ finds us back in more familiar 1989 territory and shows off both sides of Spencer’s singing. The verses are genuinely good as he sings with the control of Mike Pender and builds up to a crescendo…it’s that climax that’s awful, OTT and unbelievable as he seems to take The Searchers’ histrionic recording of ‘Solitaire’ as his template for how to sing with this band. Still, those few seconds of every chorus aside, this is one of the better songs on the album that’s genuinely sweet as Spencer becomes the perfect boyfriend, promising to always be there for his girl, to always stand beside her, to forever dry her eyes. Not since ‘Til I Met You’ have The Searchers been quite this openly romantic and it’s good to hear, love songs being one of their better suits down the years. There’s a restless riff that works quite well too, although it’s slightly edgy paranoid feeling is ever so slightly wrong for this track I feel: this song should bounce with the loved-up happy-go-luckyness of ‘When You Walk In The Room’, not glower in the corner like ‘Goodbye My Love’. This is also one of the songs on the album I would love to remix on the album the most because this is a timeless song that would work well in any era – it’s just such a shame that it happened to be made in 1989 when it works the least well, with all those synths set on what seem to be the setting ‘ugly’ just get in the way. Still, even with that problem, this is a cracking tune that sounds as if The Searchers are the right band to be singing it.

‘This Boy’s In Love’ is the closest track in feel to the new wave songs of the 1979-1981 ‘Sire’ period. It’s another 1950s sounding song updated to the slightly more fashionable sound of the early 1980s and actually all the better for it, as The Searchers get to play with the gusto and energy of old and sound very much like a youthful energetic band compared to most of their peers. This song isn’t quite as deep as perhaps it ought to be though. The song doesn’t really say much more than the title, but there is at least the feeling that this song comes as a ‘shock’. This is a middle-aged narrator whose spent his whole life, uhh, ‘searching’ for the one while all his peers were playing the field and he’s so overjoyed that this wonderful thing he’s been dreaming of for so many years has finally happened to him that he can’t contain his excitement anymore. I’d have liked to have heard more about why and what happened in the past, but I guess this narrator is too excited to think rationally so I’ll let him off that one! The Searchers sound mighty good here. Spencer sounds at his best on these straightforward gusts of energy like this song and he sounds better still when surrounded by Searchers harmonies, his straightforward voice sounding particularly good alongside Frank’s slightly more arch and sour harmonies. It’s all good fun this track and it’s good to hear the band so enthusiastic about their music again after so many years away from the studio – even if they’re effectively only doing this for their American audience.

The country-rock weepie ‘Fooled Myself Once Again’ is the best of this album’s slow songs, mostly thanks to some more excellent harmonies between the pair of singers, though it has to be said that’s a relative measure. The Searchers’ ballads can be divided in two – the songs like ‘Til I Met You’ and ‘Sea Of Heartbreak’ that are as gorgeous as any slow songs by anybody out there and the rather boring dull ones like ‘Too Many Miles’ and ‘A Tear Fell’ where not much is happening. This alas is one of the latter, where the chorus takes so many seconds to sing and is repeated so many times across the song that it feels like time is standing still, while you know where all the lyrics are going from the title alone. Basically the narrator is so desperate for love he’s fallen in love with the wrong chick, again! ‘Goodbye My Love’ this ain’t, as there’s no sense of anything ‘real’ in this song and it’s clearly written to appeal to as many teenage girls as possible, not stretch The Searchers or their sound. However a very strong band performance almost rescues this, with Spencer singing properly this time and the appearance – at long last – of some classic McNally Rickenbacker, which plays ‘across’ the song in a U2 type way rather than simply doubling what the synths are doing. You wouldn’t want to hear this track too many times, but in context it’s not bad at all.

‘Baby I Do’ is a fun second Frank vocal and an even more 1950s derivative song that in other circumstances would come surrounded in a bunch of ‘shooby-dooby-doos’. The tune sounds a little like Starship’s ‘Nothing’s Gonna Stop Us Now’, but don’t hold that against this track as the song is much more inventive, with a busy synth-bass riff that’s almost surely played by Frank and the first ‘woahs’ I’ve heard on an AAA album in some time. The lyric is as simple as it gets – Frank tries to pluck up the courage to get a girl’s number and when she asks if he loves him replies ‘Baby I do!’ But better simple and fitting than complicated and wrong; The Searchers know exactly what they’re doing and turn in their best band performance of the record, gathering round the central synth riff and everyone performing at their best. Billy’s drums, real this time, sound especially good on this song whilst Frank’s lead vocal is a delight, twinkling with mischief throughout as he tries to act pure and innocent even though by this point he’s come a long way from the young sheltered life he had before becoming a Searcher. The 1950s revival was just growing cold in 1989 as people realised just how dumb and misogynistic the story of ‘Grease’ was and how bad many of the songs actually were. This song should have inspired a whole new explosion of love for the other decade that taste forgot as it’s such infectious good fun. You sense even in 1964, though, The Searchers might have rejected this for being too ‘simple’!

‘Push Push’ is the album’s most groundbreaking song. Not necessarily good – it all sounds a bit awkward with its stop-start structure and McNally’s flamenco guitar and a cold-hearted synth and artificial drum beat are not natural bedfellows. But at least it’s a sign that The Searchers were still trying to expand their sound right up to the end of their life as a recording band (they still continue touring to this day, with everybody but Billy still in the band from this line-up). Spencer sings sweetly about needing to ‘push’ through a relationship. In the song it’s about a romance that’s grown a bit stale and where the couples have just stopped talking in quite the same billing and cooing way they did when they first met. In context, here at the end of the album The Searchers knew was going to be their last for a while, it sounds more like a message to fans that the band can’t sit still and want to push hard to break new ground the way they always used to. This is certainly a song that’s trying hard to ‘push’ boundaries, but alas it’s not that memorable, just weird. There’s also the odd aspect that as well as ‘pushing’ on, the narrator is ‘pushing’ down, keeping a lid on feelings that are rising to the surface because he doesn’t want to think about the faults in his relationship. That seems an even odder message to leave us with: while I can imagine Mike Pender writing this song based on what he thought about the band and their direction in the 1980s (there’s a lot of similarly snarky songs on his period album – or rather albums given how many times it was re-issued with ‘extra tracks down the years - which is around as good, no better or worse, than this album), this seems a very odd and troubling message for a band who should be trying to put on a united front. Maybe The Searchers pushed just a little too far with this oddly unlikeable song?

The album ends with ‘Needles and Pins ’88. Slightly more together than ‘Sweets For My Sweet ‘88’ but still rather pointless, it seems very odd hearing Spencer singing where Mike once did and yet trying to follow his style to the letter. To be fair Spencer does a really good job in a difficult situation: Many fans hadn’t realised Mike had left the band when they heard this song on the radio so close are they are they. It’s all a little fast though, performed with the same breathless enthusiasm of ‘Sweets For My Sweets ‘88’, even though it’s not really that kind of a song. It should be slow, depressed and vulnerable but the production coating gives everything a surface sheen that coats everything in some sort of a fog and the performance isn’t so much guilty and sorrowful as bright eyed and bushy-tailed. What was, in 1964, one of the most daring and pioneering singles of its day, proving that there was more to Merseybeat groups than pure adrenalin and noise, has by 1989 become part of the furniture, just another pop song that nobody really means anymore designed to sell records. Even more than ‘Sweets’, this re-recording is a real shame. Even McNally’s guitar part – the major selling point of the Searchers’ original – is reduced to a cameo and swamped with synths. Whilst proving that The Searchers are still a good band, they’ll do this song much better in period concerts and this new arrangement is a farce, the Windows Ten of AAA updates offering things that nobody wanted in the first place without asking us and taking everything that made the original inventive and quirky.

Overall, then, ‘Hungry Hearts’ is the weakest Searchers album. It makes sense that this is the album recorded in Germany as the band’s career plummeted and bashed out as quickly as possible in four goes with four different producers – it sounds fragmented and a little desperate, as any band would after seven years without a record contract. However there are nuggets of greatness throughout as The Searchers prove occasionally that they still very much have what it takes to match any other band around in 1989. The bursts of enthusiasm on a song like ‘Baby I Do’, the new pioneering sound of ‘Push Push’, the shoulda-been-a-hit of ‘Lonely Weekend’, the cleverness of the happy-yet-sadness of ‘Every Little Tear’ – there’s enough here (just about) to satisfy old-timers while if you were the main demographic for this album on release in 1989 (young teenage Germans who had a respect and interest in ‘oldie’ music but also a deep intense knowledge of the current music scene) then you’d have gone home from the shops very happy indeed. It’s now in our modern age this album has become a bit of a problem: fans who adore The Searchers in concert (as they should) naturally look for the only album by the current line-up (drummer aside) and ‘Hungry Hearts’ comes as a shock, with Spencer sounding uncomfortable and over-singing. Plus 1989 is hardly an era most fans would want to revisit and yet this album is so of its time it pretty much comes with a rubber stamp, having dated far more in thirty years than the original Searchers quintet have in fifty. Not to mention the fact that, all these decades on, it seems likely now that The Searchers’ reputation and legacy will rest here, compilations aside, rather than on a more substantial and original work. There are many reasons to hate this album now, then (the current expensive price tag being another major point against this CD) but at the time, with this album a possible stepping stone to greater things, there was and is still much to admire. The Searchers are hungry desperate for attention and even if they don’t always go about getting that attention in the right way, it’s just good to hear them at all. It would have been nice if it had ‘Sounded Like Searchers’ just a little more, but even taken for what it’s worth, as one eighth of the output of one of Britain’s greatest ever bands, most of the time it’s enough.



A NOW COMPLETE LIST OF SEARCHERS AND RELATED ARTICLES TO READ AT ALAN’S ALBUM ARCHIVES:



'It's The Searchers' (1964) http://www.alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2016/03/its-searchers-1964.html


‘Sounds Like Searchers’ (1965) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/the-searchers-sounds-like-searchers-1965.html

'Take Me For What I'm Worth' (1965)  http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2008/07/review-5-searchers-take-me-for-what-im.html


'The Searchers' (1979/1980) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2016/08/the-searchers-19791980.html


'Play For Today' aka 'Love's Melodies' (1981) http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2016/11/the-searchers-play-for-today-aka-loves.html



‘Hungry Hearts’ (1988) https://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/08/the-searchers-hungry-hearts-1989.html

Surviving TV Clips  and The Best Unreleased Recordings http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com/2017/02/the-searchers-surviving-tv-clips-1963.html


Solo Recordings 1964-1967 and 1984 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com/2017/02/the-searchers-solo-recordings-1964-1967.html


Non-Album Recordings Part One 1963-1967  http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.com/2017/02/the-searchers-non-album-recordings-part.html  


Non-Album Recordings Part Two  1968-2012 


Live/Solo/Compilation/US LPs/'Re-Recordings In Stereo’ Part One: 1964-1987 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/03/the-searchers-livesolocompilationus.html


Live/Solo/Compilation/Rarities Albums Part Two:  1990-2014 http://alansalbumarchives.blogspot.co.uk/2017/03/the-beach-boys-15-big-ones-1976.html